Re:Mixergy is now a paid subscription service for interviews...
by m0th87 on Sunday February 21, 2010 @01:38PM
(#1140998)
Not really. underover was suggesting these new accounts should be discredited because their newness and pro-Andrew bias suggests they were perhaps created by Andrew. That criticism cannot apply to him, because why would Andrew create an account to criticize himself?
Re:Mixergy is now a paid subscription service for interviews...
by bob345 on Sunday February 21, 2010 @03:22PM
(#1141178)
...and here's an account not from Argentina. Have PG check it.
Your assertion that Andrew created these new accounts is sophomoric and pathetic.
Re:Mixergy is now a paid subscription service for interviews...
by m0th87 on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:52AM
(#1143069)
I never claimed I agreed or disagreed with OP's assertions, I was merely trying to clarify the argument.
Re:Mixergy is now a paid subscription service for interviews...
by retro on Sunday February 21, 2010 @01:44PM
(#1141005)
I see what you mean but I guess I see an important difference between creating a sockpuppet in these two circumstances.
On the one hand creating an account to protect your anonymity when you make a potentially inflammatory accusation about the behavior of a prominent member of the community.
And on the other, creating an account to make it appear that you have more support on the forum than you actually have.
I find the latter to be a serious problem whereas the former seems reasonable and ethical.
[1] I have no evidence that underover is male; I'm merely using the masculine pronouns by default.