News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can a Dress Shirt Be Racist? by AnimalMuppet on Friday April 01, 2016 @08:16PM (#11409529)
I find it depressing that the sociologists are saying that race is (only) a social construct. I mean, sure, there's an element of truth to what they're saying, but there's also a truth that they're denying. We build these social constructs because there's an external reality that they... well, let's say that they oversimplify. But the external reality is there, and it isn't going away.

The external reality is that there are real, physical differences between people that correlate at least somewhat with what we perceive as "race". That's reality, whether sociologists choose to acknowledge it or to ignore it.

Re:Can a Dress Shirt Be Racist? by empath75 on Friday April 01, 2016 @11:09PM (#11410052)
So the problem with categorizing people into races is that there are many axes along which people can be divided into buckets, and any particular race grouping only has meaning in a particular place and time and will have totally arbitrary boundaries, which are as much cultural as they are genetic and physical. As long as people understand that, it's okay to talk about races tending to have certain qualities. Because culturally we've divided people based on those qualities.

But it's really important to understand that people of different races aren't different kinds of people. Any more than people who have blonde or brunette hair are different kinds of people.

Re:Can a Dress Shirt Be Racist? by qntty on Friday April 01, 2016 @11:29PM (#11410087)
>The external reality is that there are real, physical differences between people that correlate at least somewhat with what we perceive as "race".

This doesn't seem to contradict what they are saying here though.

From the article:

>Here’s what they mean: if you were to travel across the Eurasian continent from Portugal to Japan, say, there would be no river, forest or discrete boundary where people suddenly started looking “Asian” (or “European” if you traveled from east to west). Instead, changes in physical appearance would occur so gradually and imperceptibly that you probably wouldn’t notice. You’d only be aware that, once in Japan, people definitely looked different than in Portugal.

As far as I can tell, saying that race is a social construct just the age-old insight that the way we slice up the world into categories tends to be somewhat arbitrary. Race is a social construct just like species is a social construct. Why are wolves and dogs different species? You can come up with the most precise definition of species you want (which is difficult) to explain "why", but any possible definition you come up with is still somewhat arbitrary. You could have chosen a different definition which would make them the same species, or you could have split the (wolf + dog) category into three categories. This doesn't require anybody to ignore the differences between wolves and dogs. It just suggests that maybe we shouldn't get too attached to thinking of a husky as a dog, maybe it should be thought of as some in between species?