Re:The Trouble with CloudFlare
by Klathmon on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:13PM
(#11405914)
Well that's another problem. When you fill out the captcha you are given a cookie that can allow cloudflare to let you through next time.
If you are blocking that cookie for privacy reasons (which is not a bad thing!), then cloudflare has no way to verify you again (short of doing nefarious things). It's a bit of a self inflicted problem at that point.
That's not to say that the answer is "deal with it", but that we need to find a better way. A a way to verify that someone isn't a bad actor without having them take a pretty significant chunk of their time to answer captchas, or give up some of their privacy.
It's a tough problem, and i think the "proof of work" solution proposed in the original could work, but it would need participation and collaboration from "both sides" of the problem. And of course it won't happen overnight.
If you are blocking that cookie for privacy reasons (which is not a bad thing!), then cloudflare has no way to verify you again (short of doing nefarious things). It's a bit of a self inflicted problem at that point.
That's not to say that the answer is "deal with it", but that we need to find a better way. A a way to verify that someone isn't a bad actor without having them take a pretty significant chunk of their time to answer captchas, or give up some of their privacy.
It's a tough problem, and i think the "proof of work" solution proposed in the original could work, but it would need participation and collaboration from "both sides" of the problem. And of course it won't happen overnight.