Why should TOR get a pass on this when network operators need to protect their network from abuse? The choices are either 1) let the abuse continue or 2) try to block the specific attack traffic in question by heuristics which is often difficult or impossible or 3) block abusive IP addresses.
The right to privacy is not the same thing as the right to access. If someone doesn't want to allow you anonymous access it is their right to block you. Anyone using CF and not whitelisting Tor is effectively saying. If you want to visit my site you need to verify that you aren't a bad actor. If you don't want to do that because of privacy reasons then you can't visit.
It's like selling alcohol (cigarettes, porn, gambling), but not to minors.
You can say "it's OK for this crowd not OK for this crowd". Otherwise you'd probably claim that said regulation would go against the very thing that the merchant is trying to do: make as much money as possible.
It's not like that at all, because selling to everyone other than minors requires identity. Sure, you just need to verify the subject is over 18, i.e. you don't need to know name, birth date or address. But you DO need to know identity to issue the token that provisions the token that proves an age > 18.
And that breaks Tor's raison d'être.
Do you have a proposal for filtering out that kind of traffic while allowing other traffic? I can't think of a way off the top of my head and I'm sure the people behind Tor would at least consider a logical solution.
Edit: This sounds kind of confrontational, but I don't mean it like that. I honestly would like to hear of a potential solution to this because I really can't think of one.
How? If you think this was possible without completely compromising the Tor protocol, don't you think it would have been done already?
That is exactly why there is a Tor. Tor is for enabling anonymous communication. Now deciding who can do what or why would limit use and that would limit its ability to anonymous communication.