News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advanced Economies Must Still Make Things by icebraining on Friday April 01, 2016 @04:35AM (#11403500)
If you understand what people mean, why do you find it baffling?

But in any case, it's not necessarily a prescription, it can be simply an observation, as in, "advances economies must make things [if they are to remain advanced]", no different than a biologist might say "species A must increase their reproduction rate [or go extinct]".

Re:Advanced Economies Must Still Make Things by lr4444lr on Friday April 01, 2016 @09:17AM (#11404512)
I think what he's saying (and your example doesn't contradict) is that there exists a common fallacy of confusing individual firms' complex behaviors, like planning and executing a new manufacturing plant, with emergent behavior.

Similarly a species doesn't increase its reproduction rate: it grows in numbers or it shrinks (to the point of extinction) based on individual specimens' reproductive behavior. The equivalent in economics here, I think, would be net exports. Though there is correlative power between the firm and the economy, the specimen and the species, the incentives and long-term/short-term outcomes might not be aligned, which has implications for policy.