Re:The Chinese Room Argument
by telemachos on Saturday February 20, 2010 @07:29PM
(#1139806)
The meaning of words is subjective.
No. Or at least, not entirely, not in any significant way, and mostly just no.
If language were truly subjective, we should expect almost all attempts at communication to fail. If language were radically subjective, then two people speaking to each other in the same language would be for all intents and purposes like a speaker of (only) English trying to communicate to a speaker of (only) Chinese. It's manifestly the case that this isn't so. Beyond this, if language were truly subjective, we wouldn't be able to think (since the person-to-person communication problem would emerge even for one person).
The real world strikes again.
If you take the focus off the word, much of your prejudice disappears. You see the relationships, the structure, the observations, the logic, the nuance. You can see you used two distinct meanings of the word "intelligence". One is a set of expected reactions, the other is your consciousness. Now this gives rise to a logical question: Are these two things the same? The Chinese room shows that's not necessarily the case. However, might that feeling you call consciousness be a side-effect of a the particular type of Chinese room that's going on in your head? That's how you get interesting philosophy.