It doesn't work as a credential unless it actually produces results.
I had therefore never heard of it before this thread, despite it being around for 27 years now.
At the time I was in high school, US Science Olympiad, Indiana Academic Super Bowl, and the Rose-Hulman Math Competition were about the only games in town. And it was a big school. We might have had a US Chemistry Olympiad team if the chemistry teacher wasn't a few moles short of a balanced reaction, if you know what I mean. The biology and physics teachers were the Science Olympiad sponsors.
I'd think that even just being on the IOI team would be enough to get you accepted anywhere, given that you would have to be one of the top 4 students in the US for that year (by the best screening process that several university professors can manage).