News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Zak on Saturday February 20, 2010 @03:22PM (#1139415)
The facts that Flash performs just as poorly on Linux as on OS X, and far worse on a fast PowerPC (youtube is painfully choppy on a G5 Quad) than a slow x86 (youtube is tolerable on an Atom) suggest explanations that differ from the Adobe party line.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by danh on Saturday February 20, 2010 @06:51PM (#1139742)
Also, Flash often, rather surprisingly, uses more CPU cycles when a video is paused than e.g. VLC does actually playing the darned thing (on OS X).

I guess this must be because Apple doesn't allow Adobe access to its proprietary, hardware based empty loop optimizations...

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by DarkShikari on Saturday February 20, 2010 @04:09PM (#1139484)
and far worse on a fast PowerPC

This is because Mainconcept's H.264 decoder doesn't have Altivec optimizations, only x86 SIMD. The VP6 and FLV decoders, as far as I know, do have Altivec, probably because back when they were released, PowerPC was a significant market.

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by yuvi on Saturday February 20, 2010 @04:54PM (#1139563)
The best explanation I've seen is http://www.kaourantin.net/2010/02/core-animation.html when you also realize that for video playback and animation in general, OpenGL > Core Animation > Quartz 2D > QuickDraw for OS X 10.2 and newer (I think QuickDraw was better pre-compositing.)
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by papersmith on Saturday February 20, 2010 @06:57PM (#1139752)
In my experience flash under Linux was much worse than OS X. One of the main reasons I switched to OS X was to make flex development less painful.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Zak on Saturday February 20, 2010 @09:02PM (#1139925)
The overall experience is worse on Linux, with sound issues and on 64-bit Linux, clickable areas that don't line up with the visible controls. I was just talking about CPU usage.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by stevenwei on Saturday February 20, 2010 @10:58PM (#1140076)
You were doing Flex development on Linux? I'm so sorry...

We tried that once but gave up after finding out that turning on a blur filter would segfault the Flash Player. Whoops!

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by ninjac0der on Saturday February 20, 2010 @07:58PM (#1139843)
Not a good way to make your point in my opinion. 3D rendering is also slower on both OSX and linux distributions. I don't doubt Adobe and their software is a problem, but I also think it's become far to popular to blame everything on Adobe.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by the100rabh on Saturday February 20, 2010 @03:46PM (#1139442)
yeah why does Flash run so poorly on my 166Mhz P1. Crappy s/w right. Yeah its become fancy to criticize Adobe and flash, for everything.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Locke1689 on Saturday February 20, 2010 @03:58PM (#1139467)
Your account is new so I'm going to give you some advice: generally people on Hacker News have a reasonably high technical baseline and it would do you well to assume so. For example, a number of FFmpeg and x264 developers frequent the site and we have a pretty good idea of how video decoding works.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by radley on Saturday February 20, 2010 @05:44PM (#1139640)
I think it was sarcasm...
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by telemachos on Saturday February 20, 2010 @06:40PM (#1139727)
I think it was sarcasm...

A sense of which, unfortunately, is in very, very low supply around here.

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by kelnos on Saturday February 20, 2010 @08:54PM (#1139917)
I quite easily recognized it as sarcasm. But it still wasn't funny. It was just kinda dumb and obvious.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by telemachos on Saturday February 20, 2010 @09:45PM (#1139975)
I wasn't discussing whether or not the post was funny. I don't care if it was funny.

I was reacting to what I think is an occasional problem with HN. In a nutshell, some people here take "serious" so far that it turns into "puritanically self-righteously lacking in any sense or awareness of humor or irony." That can lead to really bizzare misfires of communication.

Case in point is the reaction to a recent comment by Jrockway's on the anti-IRS nutcase: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1135693 (again, please don't feel the need to say whether you find his comment funny or in poor taste or whatever).

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by kelnos on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:11PM (#1146963)
I think the comment you link to is actually kinda an odd illustration of your point[1]: the first reply (Poe's rule) clearly recognizes it as humor and suggests that others will take it overly-seriously.

The second reply is somewhere in the middle -- at least it didn't start out with "OMG you are a terrible person how could you say that!!!11" I don't know who jrockway is: maybe he's making a joke, and maybe not. It's more likely that he's making a joke, but you never can tell on teh intarwebs... even in a place like HN.

Regardless, I wouldn't consider pw0ncakes' comment puritanical or self-righteous in the least: in fact he/she slightly revels in the possibility of fat-cat execs getting their comeuppance.

[1] Though I don't disagree with your point; I have indeed seen the issue of which you speak, though I can't think of any specific examples.

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by dreyfiz on Saturday February 20, 2010 @07:09PM (#1139774)
No, it was just plain dumb.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by kierank on Saturday February 20, 2010 @08:21PM (#1139867)
To play devil's advocate a little bit it's funny how all the negativity is now focused on Adobe when not many months ago it was all focused on Apple's App Store policy.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Zak on Saturday February 20, 2010 @09:04PM (#1139931)
This article doesn't directly deal with the iPhone or app store. It's talking about Flash on desktop/laptop Macs, and as far as I can tell, the vast majority of the problems with that are Adobe's fault.

I hate that Apple has made its phone OS a walled garden. I won't buy one, and I won't develop for it, but this article doesn't really have anything to do with it.

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Zev on Saturday February 20, 2010 @08:30PM (#1139876)
Apple's fixed the criticisms from a few months ago (long submission updates, poor/inconsistent private API policy, etc). Not to say that you wouldn't have to look far to find new criticisms (their recent removal of "adult" apps, to name one).

Adobe, on the other hand, hasn't fixed any of their problems. And they've had much longer to fix their problems than Apple has. Hell, it took less time for Apple to create a problem that had to be fixed then for Adobe to fix their problems.

Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by kierank on Saturday February 20, 2010 @11:33PM (#1140130)
Well the Apple App Store problems were merely procedural issues whereas the Adobe issues are technically difficult problems that haven't been solved well by anyone and aren't helped by platform/codec war politics.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Zak on Sunday February 21, 2010 @01:49AM (#1140259)
From what I know of the issue, the technical problems with Flash are not difficult to solve. The fundamental problem seems to be that Adobe is not willing to put in the effort to make Flash work well on multiple platforms.
Re:About Adobe's Flash Player Not Having Access to H.264 HW ... by Zev on Sunday February 21, 2010 @12:27AM (#1140181)
Institutional problems can be as hard to fix as technical problems. Whats going on at Adobe might be both types of problems.

(Not to say Apple has an institutional problem, but, speaking in general.)