News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by surferbayarea on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:17PM (#11393083)
People don't care. It is funny that smart people don't care about tech and ad companies violating their privacy by collecting data and profiting from it. But they have an issue with the government doing it to protect them. Perhaps has something to do with the fact that silicon valley's success is based on the advertising business model and violation of people's privacy.
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by rz2k on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:41PM (#11393261)
Someone's going to try to sell me something I'm susceptible to buying? So what.

Authorities don't collect data on you to protect you, they are ostensibly doing it to protect other citizens from you.

One of the reasons that "smart" people object to this, is that it could also limit their ability to play a leadership role in civic life, if there are people in positions of authority with different political philosophies or, even worse, who are outright corrupt or dishonest.

Besides the obvious examples of abuse like the Nixon administration, I suspect there are very few counties in the country that don't have at least one case of someone in a sheriff department, school board, city council, etc that has been caught using their rather limited access to information about local citizens for the purpose of staying in power or for some form of personal gain.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by surferbayarea on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:59PM (#11393371)
This data should ideally be protected and owned by the individuals themselves - not the government, not the ad companies, not Google, not Facebook. As an individual who owns my data, I should have a right to decide who/when/how accesses my data.

More than a question of privacy, this is a question of next-generation user experience. If as an individual, my data from uber, google, facebook, visa, amazon is all in one place I can give selective anonymized access to it to different services that can leverage the collective data to provide better user experiences to me.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:25PM (#11393145)
For me, it has a lot to do with the fact that I have more to fear from the government collecting a lot of information about me than I do from having ad companies collecting information about me.
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by vitd on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:33PM (#11393206)
I don't know about you, but I just assume that the government is a client of the ad companies and is buying data about me from them.
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by Gustomaximus on Thursday March 31, 2016 @05:03AM (#11395863)
I'm the same. I think a big reason is trust as you mention. The other is consequence, and significance of consequence.

If a company abuses a peoples collected data they are likely just spamming them or something similar to sell me some product, and they can expect repercussions. If a government is abusing data there is likely nefarious activities happening challenging a countries democracy and little consequence to be easily had. Very different end results and motivations.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by deanCommie on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:25PM (#11393149)
Or perhaps it's because people don't trust that the government is interested in protecting them. If a private company uses the information it has on you maliciously at least you have some recourse - a competitor, or the justice system.

When the powers in charge decide to use your data against you because they don't like your political stances, who is going to protect you?

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by applel0ver on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @06:51PM (#11393638)
But at the moment, it is just some laws that are protecting you from this malicious behavior by a non-benevolent government. If such a government comes to power, why would they follow this law.

The real solution should be to use encryption so that only you as a consumer holds the keys to your data. The reason the tech industry will never implement something like this is because it will kill their profit machines - not because it is not possible to implement this.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by bitdeveloper on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:26PM (#11393157)
I think it has to do with the fact that the government can imprison you years, or for life. Even if you were breaking a law on accident, or unknowingly.

It's a matter of power imbalance.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by Dwolb on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:36PM (#11393225)
I don't think it's that simple. I believe people do care if they're getting tracked, for what reason, and for the possible repercussions.

We can compare the issues between a marketing on Facebook re-targeting you and the government recording your text messages. In one scenario, your preferences are exposed and used to present you with an advertisment to buy a good. In the other scenario, you can be analyzed for whether or not you've committed a crime or are about to commit a crime.

The two scenarios have vastly different consequences with varying levels of mindshare for thr general public.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by surferbayarea on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:41PM (#11393260)
Compare these scenarios: 1 a cop is passing by your house and sees you commit a murder. 2 government finds out from your phone's GPS data + public camera face recognition that you committed a murder 3 you admit to a murder on phone with an accomplice

Why is one way of collecting evidence any better than the other. If you commit a crime, you should be convicted. Just because you are able to hide certain types of evidence today does not make the crime justified.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by jschwartzi on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @06:48PM (#11393624)
What makes scenario 2 egregious is how easy it would be to use that evidence to implicate someone for parking nearby the victim's house while the real killer took the bus. That kind of mass data collection lets you get really convenient answers from the data, and I don't trust the police to do the additional work of physically placing me at the scene if they can get a prosecutor to railroad me using my gps data.
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by surferbayarea on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @07:16PM (#11393762)
How is that any different to the neighbor seeing you park your car in that street and not seeing the actual killer. Is there a difference in whether this evidence got collected by a person or a camera? What you do with this(and all other collected evidence) comes later. Eq - what if the government hires millions of police and place them on every intersection - that is acceptable, but having a camera on every intersection is not?
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by Dwolb on Thursday March 31, 2016 @07:51AM (#11396441)
The issue is the opposite. It's a problem this data is collected for innocent people.

It is indeed very similar to the government hiring millions of police and placing them everywhere (but even worse!). This effects society negatively and restricts freedom of expression due to the very looming presence of law enforcement everywhere.

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by mholt on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:24PM (#11393139)
> It is funny that smart people don't care about tech and ad companies violating their privacy by collecting data and profiting from it.

[citation needed]

Also define "smart."

Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by degif on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @05:32PM (#11393199)
The issue is that advertising companies do not lie about why they track me - it's about them getting more revenue and that is ok with me. But I'm not so sure about the governmental espionage protection thingy.
Re:Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participati... by megablast on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @09:05PM (#11394293)
How much can you care about? Between this, the environment, government tracking, eating well, exercising, spending time with family, friends, and many other things, you only have so much time and brain to devout to each subject.

It is easy for tech guys to talk about this, they are already involved and understand what is going on.