Re:Changes to Npm's unpublish policy
by tlrobinson on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @06:44PM
(#11385575)
Absolutely. Using shrinkwrap doesn't mean you should defer updating dependencies for weeks or months, but I've wasted enough time dealing with issues caused by minor differences in people's node_modules and things randomly breaking that I refuse to not use shrinkwrap.
Advantages:
1. Ensures everyone is developing on the exact same versions of every package
2. We have a complete record of correctly working dependencies' versions in the source tree at all times
3. Some random package developer can't introduce a bug in my software by pushing a new buggy version of their package right before I cut a release
Disadvantages:
1. You may not get bug fixes immediately. Solution: do a fresh `npm install` and `npm shrinkwrap` regularly (but not in the middle of testing a release branch, for example)
2. If someone unpublishes a version depend on you have to drop what you're doing and fix your npm-shrinkwrap.json
Also, `npm deprecate` allows package maintainers to deprecate specific versions (e.x. if a vulnerability is found), and you'll get a warning when installing, even if you use shrinkwrap. I'm not sure how common it's usage is though.
Advantages:
1. Ensures everyone is developing on the exact same versions of every package
2. We have a complete record of correctly working dependencies' versions in the source tree at all times
3. Some random package developer can't introduce a bug in my software by pushing a new buggy version of their package right before I cut a release
Disadvantages:
1. You may not get bug fixes immediately. Solution: do a fresh `npm install` and `npm shrinkwrap` regularly (but not in the middle of testing a release branch, for example)
2. If someone unpublishes a version depend on you have to drop what you're doing and fix your npm-shrinkwrap.json
Also, `npm deprecate` allows package maintainers to deprecate specific versions (e.x. if a vulnerability is found), and you'll get a warning when installing, even if you use shrinkwrap. I'm not sure how common it's usage is though.