1. Was a decent phone with a good address book
2. Provided a good web surfing experience
3. Provided a good email service
4. Fixed voicemail through visual voicemail
5. Made the carriers provide unlimited data
6. Integrated mapping with GPS
7. Music player
This combination made it a killer device.
The beatings will continue until usability improves.
But anyway, in some areas you're right. Sometimes less choice makes a device easier to use. At the same time it lowers the threshold at wich I cannot do something that I absolutely must to do. At that point "ease of use" becomes irrelevant.
That's why Apple has become utterly irrelevant to me. Obviously, many people will never hit that threshold, so Apple is going to keep on selling a lot of devices. I just can't understand how anyone calling himself (or herself) a hacker can accept the kind of limitations imposed by Apple, which are hugely more restrictive than anything Microsoft came up with even in their most evil moments.
If that doesn't match with Apple's philosophy, they should at least be upfront with the idea that you're leasing the device and that Apple reserves the right to override anything you do to it because it doesn't match their "vision".
If only there was a way Apple could ensure there were no stickers, skins, or markings on individual iPhones. Then they could really make sure no one got confused and thought the iPhone was ugly!
It's really just not worth the hassle, honestly. I will never own an iPhone primarily for these reasons.
Apart from the things which are completely unfixable by design - e.g. the iPhone's utterly standard screen size, touchscreen and lack of keyboard which means any app will work and which isn't something that can be retrofitted onto Android, and the things which it doesn't even make sense to talk about fixing, such as the already available third party apps, and the things which can't be implemented without violating Apple patents or Apple license agreements with third party companies or reverse engineering Apple sync protocols...
Apart from that, even if we agree that the amount of work is exactly the same (which I don't), that still leaves the implication that people who are interested in finding highly prized low-level exploits in iPhone software would be equally interested in (and skilled at) putting little appreciated internals and UI polish on a completely different system. Which is certainly not a given.
And that's assuming that the Android project leads would accept arbitrary and widespread changes.