News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by lotharbot on Monday March 28, 2016 @05:01PM (#11377372)
in the past, pg has used the analogy that upvotes are not only for civility, so downvotes aren't restricted only to incivility.

My own personal guideline: upvote = "I would like more comments like this" and downvote = "I would like less comments like this". My reason for wanting less comments of a particular type can be a lot of things -- incivility, factual incorrectness, being off-topic or distracting, being technically correct but misleading, or even being repetitive in relation to prior comments that already made the same point better.

Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by DanBC on Monday March 28, 2016 @05:37PM (#11377615)
PG had a few comments about downvoting. Two were like you said - people use upvote for agree so it makes sense that they downvote to disagree. But he also said that downvote for disagreement was a problem. That's (one of the) reason(s) why comment scores are no longer visible.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658683

Here's pg trying to address incorrect downvoting: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1057338

I think pg is wrong in this next comment, I think people vote to disagree, and I think there's a pile-on effect. But I don't have the data, and he (and dang) did (and do). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403716

EDIT: Some of those threads talk about the "meanness" of HN. I know I'm sometimes dumb and sometimes mean, so please if you see me doing that downvote me, flag me, send me an email.

Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by lotharbot on Monday March 28, 2016 @05:53PM (#11377709)
yeah, it's more nuanced than "downvote for disagree" or "downvote only for flagrant hostility".

It's clear that some people are using downvotes aggressively, and that needs managed. I actually had a period of time when every comment I posted (no matter what time of day or what topic) received exactly one downvote between 5 and 6 pm in my time zone, as if I'd offended someone and they were retaliating. But I've also seen people post comments that are purely inflammatory with no worthwhile content (along the lines of "[group] is evil", where [group] is mainstream -- not ISIS or Nazis, but like, Republicans or Muslims) that didn't get downvoted. So the issue is more than "too few downvotes" or "too many downvotes".

So I try to be part of HN's corrective mechanism. If I see something blatantly inappropriate, I downvote and flag if appropriate. If I see something reasonable that's grayed out, I upvote. If I see something non-gray that I think is of negative value, I downvote, and I hope that if I misjudged it someone else will come along and cancel out my vote.

Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by r00fus on Monday March 28, 2016 @07:37PM (#11378382)
huh - maybe HN should have some sort of Karma modifiers like Slashdot did?