Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers
by crux_ on Friday February 19, 2010 @02:34PM
(#1137714)
> "discredited scientist lashes out at his critics (some of whom are poor journalists and/or political mouth-pieces)" with "scientists try to silence someone who doesn't tow the party line."
But here's the rub: How do you know which is which? Well, if you agree with one party, it's the former; and if you don't, it's the latter.
The incident I mentioned is the centrepiece of "Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed" -- a documentary about how the evolutionary biology community allegedly silences anyone who doesn't tow the party line.
The only reason that I would find the latter to be okay, would be if the paper itself was fairly substandard. Then I could see a boycott of (or outrage against) the journal in question for publishing something that doesn't meet certain standards in an effort to maybe gain readership through controversy (e.g. if they publish a paper where the only 'evidence' presented that supports certain conclusions is quotes from the Bible or the Qur'an, I wouldn't think it that outrageous for people to be disappointed in the journal for even allowing it to be published).
I would appreciate a link to the incident that you are talking about as I don't follow the news that closely anymore.