News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by jerf on Friday February 19, 2010 @12:59PM (#1137453)
Did the epidemiologist in your question participate in deliberately preventing peer-reviewed studies about vaccine safety being published? Did the evolutionary biologist deliberately block peer-reviewed studies from being published? And then go on about how there's no peer-reviewed evidence?

(The combo is more distressing than just manipulating the peer review process alone. Doing that you could argue is just firm belief that the other side isn't science, but then using that as an argument against their position makes it hard for me to conclude anything but malice here.)

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by crux_ on Friday February 19, 2010 @01:22PM (#1137506)
To answer your questions: Probably yes, and certainly yes. The intelligent design movement has made a whole documentary film about their systematic exclusion from the scientific process, for pete's sake!

For a specific example, a biology journal associated with the Smithsonian published an intelligent design paper -- and as a result, its publisher was immediately forced out, and the newly installed publisher printed a complete retraction. Further, many evolutionary biologists don't just work to prevent ID papers from being published; they actively advocate shutting down any journals that do publish it...

The thing is, if you believe that evolution is on solid footing, and the ID movement's attempts to cast doubt on it are junk science, then all of the above is perfectly appropriate -- but if you believe that evolution is actually a flawed theory, then all of the above is evidence of ideologically driven 'bad science'! The parallels continue.

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by Nwallins on Friday February 19, 2010 @01:34PM (#1137538)
> The intelligent design movement has made a whole documentary film about their systematic exclusion from the scientific process, for pete's sake!

And so on with Astrology, Alchemy, and the Humours theory of medicine. These things are not science and do not deserve the dignity and resources of scientific consideration. ID is an unverifiable postulation (with no explanatory power) about the origins of the universe, whereas the IPCC kerfuffle is all about scientists wanting to do science, review the data, etc.

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by crux_ on Friday February 19, 2010 @01:52PM (#1137602)
Thank you for the opportunity to (re-)make my point.

Think if someone had said these exact words about climate sceptics: "These things are not science and do not deserve the dignity and resources of scientific consideration."

Outrageous, unscientific arrogance. If you believe the sceptics have a point. But if you don't, it's completely justified (although politically unwise to say out loud).

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by Nwallins on Friday February 19, 2010 @02:11PM (#1137645)
In my mind, the question is not whether the skeptics have a point -- it's whether they are doing science. We are presuming that the IPCC is doing science and that the skeptics are doing science. The skeptics may be wrong, and they may not have a point, but they are doing science.

Drawing an analogy to evolution skeptics of the ID variety confounds the issue, because there is no presumption of science being done by the skeptics. I suggest you choose a more faithful analogy.

EDIT, in consideration of

> "These things are not science and do not deserve the dignity and resources of scientific consideration."

That is a bold claim by anti-skeptics, and the burden of proof is on them. Claiming that ID is not science is not so bold, and I can back that up if you really need such.

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by crux_ on Friday February 19, 2010 @02:26PM (#1137688)
> The skeptics may be wrong, and they may not have a point, but they are doing science.

If they were really doing science, you'd think they could get something published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal instead of just blogging, wouldn't you? ;)

(Aaaand we've come full circle!)

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by Nwallins on Friday February 19, 2010 @02:45PM (#1137759)
OK, so we are down to the crux of the issue. ;) The claim, then, is that the skeptics are not doing science. That is easily refutable, e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_McIntyre and http://www2.macleans.ca/2009/12/13/centre-of-the-storm/print...

Thus, in contrast to evolution skeptics of the ID variety, climate skeptics give much more credence to the idea that the target of their skepticism is flawed at best, and doing bad science at worst.

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by crux_ on Friday February 19, 2010 @03:07PM (#1137831)
> The claim, then, is that the skeptics are not doing science. That is easily refutable

Phil Jones doesn't think it's so easily refutable, does he? It's the only non-conspiracy-theory explanation of the tone of the email leaks, and makes a ton of sense.

[[ Sidebar:

Personally I'm not so sure sceptics are "doing science" either. They don't seem to do much hypotheses forming, nor experimentation, nor evidence gathering... They are only pointing out potential flaws in the work of those who are actually doing the full spectrum of activity. Absolutely: There is real scientific value in that.

However, when you couple it with the fact that the vast majority of their efforts are aimed at the court of public opinion and not a scientific dialogue with other scientists, it starts to smell fishy to me.

]]

All of that aside: your entire point above was that you find the sceptics plausible -- that's fine, but realize that my point in posting the 'thought experiment' is that your interpretation of mainstream climate science as a horrible scandal rests entirely on your judgement of McIntyre etc as legitimate in the first place.

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by stonemetal on Friday February 19, 2010 @02:41PM (#1137742)
Publishing has nothing to do with weather or not they are doing science. It has to do with the methodology they employ.
Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by jerf on Friday February 19, 2010 @02:59PM (#1137804)
No, you got it backwards. It wasn't those challenging the consensus redefining "peer review", it was the scientific consensus in this case. Consensus was manufactured. You cite examples in the opposite direction.

(One can argue about what the real breakdown of opinions on global warming are with the real scientists, but it's objective truth that it is not 100% agreement within the science, or even close to that.)

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by nollidge on Friday February 19, 2010 @04:51PM (#1138066)
> it's objective truth that it is not 100% agreement within the science, or even close to that.

Source? If the IPCC is at all representative of climate scientists at large, then I'd say they're pretty close to 100%.

Re:'Climategate' scientist attacks bloggers by guelo on Friday February 19, 2010 @01:33PM (#1137535)
What evidence do you have that any papers where blocked? The papers discussed in the email - McKitrick and Michaels (2004) and Kalnay and Cai (2003) - where both published and even referenced in the IPCC.

One frustrated scientist doesn't have the power to "redefine what the peer-review literature is"