News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Asset Managers: The tide turns by lordnacho on Saturday March 26, 2016 @02:55PM (#11366890)
I certainly think they are smart guys, but I doubt whether what they are doing is highly complex in the sense of being inexplicable to ordinary math graduates.

Like with a lot of math, you learn more about the basics once you are on to the advanced stuff.

And the more advanced stuff you learn, the more you see limitations. Very advanced can very well mean brittle.

I reckon what they have is a well distilled common sense setup where they are able to reject models that appear to be profitable but aren't. I'm guessing they are also able to procedurally generate models that capture the same few common sense notions in new ways as the market evolves. In contrast I reckon most quant shops are still at a stage where the models are hand coded, causing some severe issues that I'll touch upon.

There's also an organisational aspect about them. They're all very very good at math. Any BS is likely to get rumbled. Intellectual carelessness will probably be detected and the boss is a proper math guy too. Here's a subtle thing that many people I've worked with would not detect: to calculate my fund's information ratio, I take the monthly returns, average them, and divide by the standard deviation. I have to multiply by root 12 because there's 12 months in a year. Standard procedure.

Having worked with some mere mortals I can tell you a lot of time is spent convincing oneself of the intellectual merits of something one's found despite evidence to the contrary. I think the fact that quants tend to be low quality coders with high internal prestige causes a lot of funds to do less well than they should. A lot of effort goes into hand tuning models rather than trying a bunch of different ones. You get things like unconscious "optimizations" that are very hard to spot, and hard to argue against because the person doing the talking is of high rank.

There are no comments on this comment yet.