Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians Are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)
by jmcmichael on Friday March 25, 2016 @03:46PM
(#11362203)
> If not, by what means to propose that we do so?
>> Quite easy really. Whether a person is a danger to society or not, should be determined by a court jury based on his previous actions.
A couple of problems with this solution come to mind. You say that the knowledge that psychiatry produces is invalid because it is non-scientific. The process by which the justice system produces knowledge is decidedly non-scientific and inherently subjective. Why do you hold the knowledge produced by the non-scientific process of justice above the non-scientifically produced knowledge of psychiatry?
Additionally, by the time the justice system gets involved, a crime against society has already occurred. Surely we can do better than waiting for tragedy before intervening?
>> Quite easy really. Whether a person is a danger to society or not, should be determined by a court jury based on his previous actions.
A couple of problems with this solution come to mind. You say that the knowledge that psychiatry produces is invalid because it is non-scientific. The process by which the justice system produces knowledge is decidedly non-scientific and inherently subjective. Why do you hold the knowledge produced by the non-scientific process of justice above the non-scientifically produced knowledge of psychiatry?
Additionally, by the time the justice system gets involved, a crime against society has already occurred. Surely we can do better than waiting for tragedy before intervening?