Re:The Immobile Masses: Why Traffic Is Awful and Public Tran...
by yummyfajitas on Friday March 25, 2016 @04:10PM
(#11362321)
The government can't exclude people who don't pay for the lighthouse from using it. It's all or nothing - hence not excludible.
A subway can exclude anyone who doesn't pay while including anyone who does. To take the example of several subways I've been on recently (NYC, Delhi, Amsterdam, Boston), if you don't pay the turnstile won't let you through.
If you scroll up, you'll find me explicitly agreeing that roads are a private good which should be paid for via user fees (either gas or odometer taxes), and those who refuse to pay should be excluded.
Re:The Immobile Masses: Why Traffic Is Awful and Public Tran...
by snowwrestler on Friday March 25, 2016 @04:21PM
(#11362393)
Okay, I'll think about this. Thanks for the discussion. Have a good weekend.
Even the wikipedia page is hilariously mixed up, listing a public lighthouse as a public good, even though a person needs to own a ship to benefit from the lighthouse (excluding most people), only so many ships can pass through a section of the sea at one time (making it rivalrous), and of course the government can just turn off the light whenever it wants (excluding everyone).
Edit to add: if a road or a park or a lighthouse can be a public good, then so can a subway. If a subway can't be a public good, then neither can a road, a park, or a lighthouse, since they all violate the definition in similar ways.