Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians Are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)
by jmcmichael on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:25PM
(#11360938)
Do you believe that mental disorders exist? If so, how would you go about identifying and treating them? If not, what empirically verifiable means do you know of to identify people who are a danger to themselves or society, and treat them?
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians Are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)
by emodendroket on Monday March 28, 2016 @09:25AM
(#11374091)
While I think there's something to the idea that mental illness is largely determined by consensus and probably some of the diseases shouldn't be treated as such, it's hard to say something like extreme paranoia, hallucinations, or depression with suicidal ideation wouldn't be a problem if not for our cultural beliefs.
1) Every individual is statistically abnormal. That's how they're identifiable. It's debated amongst professionals because there are absolutely no consistent criteria for behavioural normality that wouldn't include wide swaths of undistressed people.
2) is incoherent in practice. Mental disease is diagnosed in people because they are not distressed by things that "should" distress people. Mental disease is also diagnosed if people are distressed by the reaction of others to their symptoms, not by the symptoms themselves.
3) "reasonable change" is a hint that 3) is completely arbitrary.
The context that the concept of non-physical mental disorder is bound in is a historical accident, non-physical mental disease doesn't translate between cultures (entirely culturally-bound and fashion-following), and most of our current concepts of mental disease have origins dependent on things like the order in which we happened to discover certain neurotransmitters and superstitions about epileptic seizures making people sane.
Mental illness is defined as when you don't get your work done, or you make it difficult for other people to get their work done. All of the handwaving around it, and the fabricated physical theories applied to a wide range of "disorders" that largely amount to disobedience and differing opinions and values, corrupt our society and undermine democracy. You take the drugs and you do what you're told, or you will be medicated for your own protection. It's also class/race-based - the range of behaviors a suburban white girl would be medicated for are largely different than the ones an inner city black boy would be medicated for, even though they would get the same diagnosis (since diagnoses are based on "distress.")
This is not new. Every third rebellious kid I knew in high school 25 years ago was diagnosed with Oppositional Defiant Disorder or Bipolar Disorder, and had month-long stints in mental hospitals that began when they stayed out all night that one time, or flunked a semester, or got caught drinking or smoking pot. ADD wasn't quite as trendy then, and the range of products being sold to parents for it was narrower.