I'd argue that the investment strategies you're describing are actually creating value. Getting information about carcinogens out into the world is a plus for sure. Another instance of this is Herbalife which is looking more and more like a Ponzi scheme thanks to an activist investor.
Welcome to the era of regulation through speculation.
Imo I believe John Hempton's take on Herbalife, which is that what they sell is not the supplement but a "sense of community" that the participants strongly desire.
He says he was never good in the lab but was always proficient and prolific at reading papers, and finds it to be a bit of a calling for him.
But the point here is Paulson has been unable to replicate his success. He extracted huge money in his commodity funds while losing a lot of investor money.
So while you're right that these opportunities will exist, and that people will be required to extract them, I'd say there is no proof that these folks are more or less likely to generate returns into the future. It would be interesting to see if, like active mutual funds, there is no correlation between past returns and future returns for activist funds.
The problems seem similar in spirit: extracting a signal through side-channels. It's obvious that there's a ton of runway left to do this stuff in the investment space, and with the amount of money to be made, plenty of cash to pay for it.
How is that not considered insider trading, in the light of what happened to the Capital One fraud researchers? Both are using information that's not available to the whole market.
The rules around this stuff just seem very arbitrary.
Technicaly it isn't insider trading as they aren't getting data from the company. They are guessing it from a private company that is exempt from such guidance.
Unless you can explain otherwise, it's exactly analogous to the situation described above.
http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-01-23/capital-one...
There is absolutely no doubt that an algorithm can outperform most asset managers using traditional strategies quite well, but their implied thesis is wrong. It is extremely unlikely that any system short of an AGI, no matter how sophisticated, will be able to displace all active managers.
The reason behind that is that the best active managers try to build up positions by creating an informational edge. The very best ones are willing to do whatever it takes. Some have specialists analysing satellite imagery. Others are willing to snap up equity in private competitors of a company to check out their orderbook to predict the reality of the market before it can be reflected by the market. Or fund studies and do their own work. Whatever it takes.
A really great example of this trend is the rise of activist hedge funds which work by shorting the market and exposing malfeasance at companies. Last year an activist hedge fund manager, Whitney Tilson, found out that the products of Lumber Liquidators was laced with a carcinogen. He had lab tests conducted, shorted the stock, announced his results publicly, and created a media campaign around it resulting in a tumble. http://seekingalpha.com/article/3019166-lumber-liquidators-i...
It is extremely unlikely that any system could have replicated Tilson's work, because none of this data was online or existed somewhere that could be easily queried. At best these systems can trade far more effectively humans can with existing strategies, but that does not mean they can produce great returns, as they're operating upon the information the market already knows, as opposed to seeking out what isn't known.
There are similar examples within commodities - there are firms that specialise in using satellite imagery to predict if OPEC has increased production or what the global yield of rice / wheat is going to be. (case in point http://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2015-07-08/satellite-... ) There is an arms race going on right now to know what the state of any economy will be before anyone else knows it. They will continue to specialise along this route by funding remote sensing companies, putting money into internet analytics to predict future usage patterns, and everything else they can think of before anyone else.
Machines just can't compete - at least, for now.