First, Hong Kong has such low taxes because the government makes most of their money by leasing and selling land. They don't need much to bring in as much tax revenue because of this. Their low tax rate has little to do with being more efficient or "prioritizing infrastructure."
Second, why are you using the marginal tax rate for San Fransisco? You should be using the effective tax rate which is much much lower than 50%.
Why is it not OK for China PR to manipulate the RMB but it is OK for Texas to lower worker rights to attract business? And no, I don't believe in this "laboratories of democracy" bs. There are things in which uniqueness is good but there are other times when we need a standard (you know like the Constitution and the bill if rights).
Now, I'd be all for a low tax, maybe 0.1% (due annually) of property value so that someone who owns one million dollars of land and building will pay $1000 extra each year. I'd go further and say no exceptions (not even non profit or charity) just to illustrate a simple problem: we don't know how to do any redistribution.
Should this new tax go directly to the county government to spend as they wish? Should it go to the state so they can take money from Lawrence and spend it in Kansas City, KS? Should it go to the federal government so it can spend more in Iowa than the tax raised from Iowa? I am just bringing this up because I've thought about the fetish among some people that everything would be OK if the federal government just backed off and let the state governments take charge. The problem is it wouldn't really fix the problem. I don't think Divide and conquer really works like this because we haven't divided the problem enough. Our States are too big themselves.
I guess my main point is that as long as the tax rate is uniform across the whole system regardless of location, I could live with a small land/house tax not exceeding 0.1% of property value so that a person with a million dollar house pays $1000 each year. The problem is in how we spend this money. Does the money have to be spent in the same neighborhood? Town? County? State? Country?
At my company there was talk of moving it to Boston, but I refused to consider doing it.
The competition between states gives all of us more liberty to choose places that govern their states differently.
Six figures is table stakes for living in the Bay Area, and I certainly don't want to see the BART staffed by people who live so far away they don't even ride it.
Not the lowest taxes still, but I'm bewildered as to where does some of this myth of the 10+% state income tax comes from.
At a glance, this seems like a very reasonable estimate:
How much does a Surgeon in San Francisco, CA make?
The median annual Surgeon salary in San Francisco, CA is
$435,890, as of February 22, 2016, with a range usually
between $368,625-$517,331 not including bonus and benefit
information and other factors that impact base pay."
http://www1.salary.com/CA/San-Francisco/surgeon-salary.htmlWhere you do get your $150K-$200K estimate from?
The primary cause appears to be the way the US solicits and manages infrastructure projects which leads to massive bloat and inefficiency.
[1] https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/us-r...
[2] https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/06/03/comp...
[3] http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2012-08-26/u-s-taxpaye...
> The primary cause appears to be the way the US solicits and manages infrastructure projects which leads to massive bloat and inefficiency.
This is depressing. What can we, as voters or political donors or investors or entrepreneurs, do to fix it?
The US has well organized and effective political advocacy groups for a number of causes. For example, there's one whose sole focus is maximizing people's gun rights.
We need one for ending bureaucratic bloat, corruption, rent seeking and pork. A group whose sole goal is to fix government so we can get projects done cleanly and on time and at reasonable cost.
because you own part of the businesses a huge amount of your expenses are either deductible or simply covered by the business, which then deducts it from its earnings (which are probably getting passed through to you directly). lunch and some dinners, ambiguous trips to major cities, car lease, laptops, phones, christmas gifts, etc. also, a lot of people just straight up buy shit for their house on the business dime like nice TVs, furniture, etc. field audit? move it to the office.
sales (you call it VAT .. okay) tax is probably high, but it's optional, you don't have to actually buy anything. also, you can buy stuff in cheaper places, especially if you and own a second home in a lower tax area (which many people do).
The only real ways I'm aware of to get taxes much lower is capital gains, or perhaps real estate where depreciation "losses" defer a lot of taxes on your income.
But neither of those would really be available for partners in a law firm or medical practice.
So again, please elaborate on how partners get taxed at 20%?
That's just not true.
We have crumbling infrastructure because we refuse to prioritize it due to political dysfunction.
If youre a surgeon or a lawyer living in San Francisco, your marginal tax rate is 39.5% federal + 11% state. Over 50%. You also pay 8.75% VAT on a lot of common purchases and 1% property tax.
This is not a low tax environment.
Hong Kong has a 15% flat tax and yet they have vastly better infrastructure than we do. Singapore is a similar story. Even Istanbul, with per capita income and tax collection thats a small fraction of ours, has a great light rail system that puts Bart to shame. Istikal Street is incredible--imagine Market and Mission put together, and pedestrian only. It is a beautiful city.
So how do these places do it?
* They respect and prioritize infrastructure
* Their governments are less gridlocked
* They value density and walkability
* They have fewer NIMBYs, with much less power to obstruct
* They're less lawsuit-friendly. In the Bay every big infra project spends time and money fighting lawsuits.
* They have leaner bureaucracies. BART has tons of six figure salaries on the payroll for random adminstrative positions.