News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CardPool (YC W10) Wants To Buy And Sell Your Unused Gift ... by Retric on Thursday February 18, 2010 @07:15PM (#1135780)
They set the buy and sell price, so there is no auction component.
Re:CardPool (YC W10) Wants To Buy And Sell Your Unused Gift ... by apsurd on Thursday February 18, 2010 @07:31PM (#1135808)
http://www.giftcardrescue.com/

was one of the sharktank companies, meaning they got national tv promotion as well.

The thing I can see cardpool executing on better is user-experience, but is that enough?

This reminds me of companies like ebay, godaddy, and cashforgold. It's ridiculous to see how spammy and ui-horrific these sites/models are... but they are huge companies nonetheless.

Re:CardPool (YC W10) Wants To Buy And Sell Your Unused Gift ... by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 19, 2010 @07:59AM (#1136778)
Warning: avatar audio starts without warning at that link.
Re:CardPool (YC W10) Wants To Buy And Sell Your Unused Gift ... by tesseract on Thursday February 18, 2010 @09:20PM (#1135982)
Having a disinterested party set the prices seems unlikely to work (sustainably/scale-ably). A bid/ask system (like the stock market) seems like a decent model, although it might be difficult to present in a way that is easy for most users to understand.

Just like in the real markets there would room for a market-maker to make money on the bid-ask spread, while providing liquidity... if the service had an API, this could be a third party, although the more obvious scenario is that CardPool itself would be the market maker.

Re:CardPool (YC W10) Wants To Buy And Sell Your Unused Gift ... by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 19, 2010 @08:06AM (#1136795)
None of the parties is disinterested.

If I purchase £50 GBP giftcard, then my friend wants to swap that in for 80% of the value, they get £40 to spend elsewhere. Now if CardPool sell the card back to the company for £45 they're both splitting the remaining £10. CardPool don't need the customer buyers in order to buy cards. They could presumably also deal with the companies to buy cards direct at a discount (as if they were an affiliate).

CardPool then have a few options. If they lower the swap value of company A then I'm more likely to use my money there. This can actually be bad for company A as whilst they can negotiate a potentially larger amount of the difference of a buy-back they also risk the customer keeping the card and actually using it. Which is a transactional loss for them but a potential win if they can gain repeat custom.

It's really quite interesting to consider the back room deals that might go on over this.

Re:CardPool (YC W10) Wants To Buy And Sell Your Unused Gift ... by seanos on Thursday February 18, 2010 @07:22PM (#1135793)
Plastic Jungle seem to sell them at fixed prices too, although the price is set by the seller. Why is having a third party, CardPool, set the price an advantage? Surely they are going to have to price them at the market value anyway?