Re:Gx: A package management tool built around IPFS
by narrowrail on Thursday March 24, 2016 @12:06PM
(#11353934)
This comment demonstrates that you do not have any criticism at all regarding this project. While reading it I could only think of Visual Source Safe and Git, which I believe counters your entire premise.
Re:Gx: A package management tool built around IPFS
by peterwwillis on Thursday March 24, 2016 @03:04PM
(#11355451)
Git was created basically because there wasn't an open source implementation of BitKeeper, and BitKeeper was unique in its function. If at all possible Torvalds would have stayed away from making Git (in fact he said so himself). This is different than reinventing a wheel with existing functionality. I don't see how VSS relates, since it's used for different things (like comparing Oracle to SQLite?)
Non-corporate tools, on the other hand, are typically made by people who need to do something and want to do it their own way. It's not that they couldn't make due with an existing tool - the functionality probably existed in another tool or tools - they just want to do it differently, with some kind of interesting twist. The end result? Reinventing the wheel with maybe one new feature, and missing all the ones they didn't need/want. Do this a hundred times and you have a hundred tools that are useful to some people, but not most people.
I'm not saying it's lame, i'm saying it's a waste of engineering effort.