Re:Redox – A Unix-Like Operating System Written in Rust
by nickpsecurity on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @07:30PM
(#11349230)
Mach was a microkernel that tried to do a bit too much. Performance and security stayed horrible. Other designs had acceptable to great performance or security. So, it's not representative of microkernels in general despite being interesting research platform back in its own day.
Now, Darwin starts with Mach then basically adds BSD and graphic stack onto it in kernel mode. So, stuff that would have user-mode isolation and performance penalties due to Mach bloat has no penalty but less protection.
So, OS X is clearly not a microkernel system so much as incorporating a microkernel into a monolith. Windows similarly has a microkernel near its foundation for organization purposes I think. Linux is really modular inside similar to microkernels but clearly similarity ends there. So, there's lots of hybrid results where monoliths and microkernels styles are blended a bit for compromise of bensfits.
Now, Darwin starts with Mach then basically adds BSD and graphic stack onto it in kernel mode. So, stuff that would have user-mode isolation and performance penalties due to Mach bloat has no penalty but less protection.
So, OS X is clearly not a microkernel system so much as incorporating a microkernel into a monolith. Windows similarly has a microkernel near its foundation for organization purposes I think. Linux is really modular inside similar to microkernels but clearly similarity ends there. So, there's lots of hybrid results where monoliths and microkernels styles are blended a bit for compromise of bensfits.