News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by bsder on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @07:05PM (#11349036)
> if I can be mildly affective at a job, and the environment changes, and I don't keep up, why should I be given preference...

Seniority and firing are two different things.

Seniority kicks in when there are layoffs. You have to lay the younger people off first. This prevents management from using "layoffs" to suddenly reduce their salaries by swapping out all younger people for all older people.

Firing is available at any age. However, the union will force you to DOCUMENT it. The problem is that management almost never wants to document things because it invariably makes management look bad--their demands look silly, the historical record is against them, end users love the person they are attempting to fire, etc. The reason for this is that the number of people actually being fired for being grossly incompetent/work hazard/etc. is dwarfed by the number of people management is trying to fire for political reasons.

Yeah, you all have apocryphal stories of the youngsters being disadvantaged. I have real stories of being part of strikes, the abuse companies used to try to push people out before they could get their full retirement benefits, reassignment of roles to abuse someone for speaking out about dangerous conditions, etc.

And, those of you who suggest that lawyers are the answer have never actually sued someone. I have. And won. It would have been more profitable for me to lose if it had happened 3 years earlier. The law is expensive and slow.

Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by ef4 on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @10:00PM (#11350049)
> before they could get their full retirement benefits

Is it any wonder that young people are extremely skeptical of defined-benefit plans?

I for one would never want a job where that was a significant part of the pay package. Cash on the barrel head, please. Even if I trust you now, I can't possibly trust whoever is going to be running the company thirty years from now.

It's like agreeing to get paid partially in IOUs or company scrip. It seems like an obvious scam, and I can't relate at all to people who long to go back to that pattern.

Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by fennecfoxen on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @07:19PM (#11349155)
> you all have apocryphal stories of the youngsters being disadvantaged.

The big disadvantage is for youngsters is being utterly unemployed. Notice that in places like highly-unionized France youth unemployment is something like 25%+. That's not apocryphal, that's we-got-tons-of-data.

Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by bsder on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @08:22PM (#11349561)
And in the US we're finding the same percentages as older workers replace younger workers in jobs like food services that traditionally employed younger kids.

We also have lots of stories of H1-B's replacing workers even in the youthful age brackets. That's the sort of thing that seniority rules also prevent.

It ain't unions causing the problems.

You would do well to cogitate on the real causes instead of just swallowing the anti-union propaganda.

Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by VanillaLime on Thursday March 24, 2016 @01:04AM (#11350698)
The youth unemployment rate in the US is around 10 percent. I'd say a two and a half times difference is pretty significant.

Would you rather move to San Francisco or Paris straight out of college? Which you do think has better career prospects? Do you think that has anything to do with the extreme difficulty of hiring and firing workers in France?

Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by bsder on Thursday March 24, 2016 @02:30AM (#11350980)
Yet, if I look here:

http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/2995521/7197743/3-010...

One of the most unionized countries (Germany) has one of the lowest unemployment rates.

So, apparently the issue isn't unions.

> Would you rather move to San Francisco or Paris straight out of college?

Unfortunately, THAT ISN'T AN OPTION. Immigration policies specifically block the ability to do that.

And, personally, if I did have the option, I suspect going to Berlin and joining the union is the best option.

Re:Rule to Require Employers to Disclose Use of Anti-Union C... by tracker1 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @02:16PM (#11355054)
I just want to clarify, that I'm not against unionizing or collective bargaining... it's part of capitalism at work. I just wanted to point out that seniority really doesn't mean anything in and of itself.