Re:Klisp – An implementation of the Kernel programming language
by qwertyuiop924 on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @10:22AM
(#11344696)
Okay. So this is essentially the "eval is slow" problem all over again. If that's the problem, then it's endemic to all Lisps. Fexprs just encourage that style of programming.
According the summary of the Wand paper, though, another problem is that optimizations can't happen without full-program analysis. And now the question becomes, if fexprs can be trivially implemented in lisp using macros, or just hand-quoting args, then why don't non-fexpr lisps have this issue? And if they do, why don't we just add fexprs, and first class environments, and eliminate macros entirely?
According the summary of the Wand paper, though, another problem is that optimizations can't happen without full-program analysis. And now the question becomes, if fexprs can be trivially implemented in lisp using macros, or just hand-quoting args, then why don't non-fexpr lisps have this issue? And if they do, why don't we just add fexprs, and first class environments, and eliminate macros entirely?