Re:Why mental health idealism might not overcome the market
by Avshalom on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @09:33PM
(#11341447)
It's that way in at least some cases in the US too. I mean no one has any sympathy for sex offenders but for instance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalinga_State_Hospital can/does hold people indefinitely.
Every single one of them said they preferred the prison to the hospital.
This is because prisoners have sentences that they serve, but patients don't - they're just treated until they're well enough to go back to the prison population.
In general "I have a severe mental illness" is not enough to help a defendant get off. The test is something like "I have a severe mental illness, and it was controlling me during my time, and I did not know what I was doing". If we just look at the population of people with a mental illness we see that most of them don't meet this strict requirement.
Of course, this in England. I guess things are different in the US.