News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday February 18, 2010 @08:42AM (#1134085)
If this violated child pornography laws, we will get the remarkable outcome that a school system is not allowed within 2500 feet of a school. So it's not all bad!
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by cduan on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:00AM (#1134406)
There doesn't appear to be a claim in the complaint regarding any child pornography laws yet. But who knows--that may change if new photos turn up during discovery.

Here's some thoughts on the Fourth Amendment illegal search claim, at least:

There is this 2001 case, Kyllo v. United States, that held it illegal for the police to use a thermal scanner to detect heat lamps in a guy's house (the heat lamps being used to grow marijuana). The Supreme Court held, in an opinion by Justice Scalia:

"Where...the Government uses a device that is not in general public use, to explore details of the home that would previously have been unknowable without physical intrusion, the surveillance is a 'search' and is presumptively unreasonable without a warrant."

Seems to me this case falls pretty squarely within the Kyllo rule. Maybe webcams are in public use, but a spy program connected to a webcam and operated by someone other than the possessor of the computer would probably not be. The webcam photos were of the inside of a home, and those photos could not have otherwise been taken without going inside the home.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by CWuestefeld on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:14PM (#1134648)
There is this 2001 case, Kyllo v. United States, that held it illegal for the police to use a thermal scanner to detect heat lamps

I don't think that's precisely correct. It's not illegal -- the cops aren't going to be sent to jail. It just makes the evidence inadmissible.

And that subtlety makes all the difference in this application.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by dpatru on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:39PM (#1134721)
An unlawful search is illegal. Whether the cop go to jail depends on if they're convicted of a criminal law.

Usually an illegal search is brought up as a defense by the person who was searched and is now being charged with evidence obtained in the search. The issue in these cases is whether the fruits of the illegal search should be used against the person who was searched. (See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exclusionary_rule)

An illegal search is in all cases a violation of a right and therefore the person who was searched has a legal remedy. This is the basis of the suit by the students against the school (see the pdf at the bottom of the article.)

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by CWuestefeld on Thursday February 18, 2010 @02:17PM (#1134985)
An unlawful search is illegal. Whether the cop go to jail depends on if they're convicted of a criminal law.

As far as I'm aware this never happens, or at least I've never heard of it. But then, IANAL.

Not that I disbelieve you, but I'm curious. Can you cite some real-life cases where officers that poked their noses where they ought not have later been prosecuted and actually been punished? My guess is that they'll be protected by qualified immunity. (but then, that immunity probably isn't available in the case at hand)

Anecdote: I have a friend who was handing out pamphlets in front of the post office on Tax Day. He was arrested and later sued for 1st Amendment violations. He won his case against the town, but the prosecution against the officers failed because they thought they were doing the right thing (with no acknowledgment of the fact that their job makes it critical for them to have this knowledge).

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by cduan on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:09PM (#1136150)
Fair enough, I should have been more precise with my language.

Section 1983 says that a violation of a constitutional right gives rise to a civil remedy for damages. A violation of the Fourth Amendment right is such a violation of a constitutional right. If the school officials, being officers of the state, did not comply with the rule in Kyllo, then they would be in violation of the Fourth Amendment, so they could be liable for damages under section 1983.

The officials could defend on the grounds of qualified immunity. However, to win on this defense, the officers must show that the law was not "clearly established." The argument I would make is that Kyllo is clearly established, so qualified immunity would not apply.

The Wikipedia article on section 1983 provides some examples of its uses:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_1983

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by furyg3 on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:29AM (#1134515)
That's with regard to a crime, however, not a school policy.

You may very well be allowed to die your hair blue, have a "legalize weed" bumper sticker on your guitar case, or an explicit novel in your backpack off campus, but if you do any of those things on-campus you violate school rules and can be punished.

Furthermore, even things you do off-campus can violate your school's code of conduct (writing about how much your teacher sucks publicly on Facebook), and you can be punished at school.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by scott_s on Thursday February 18, 2010 @01:14PM (#1134821)
The school, however, can not violate the law in order to learn about actions which are against the school's code of conduct.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by timwiseman on Thursday February 18, 2010 @05:36PM (#1135525)
Where the lines are drawn as to what activities done off-campus that can be punished on campus (such as talking badly about your teacher) is a legally contentious issue right now. Here is a basic writeup of one currently ongoing case: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/02/student-susp...

(And obviously, IANAL).

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by protomyth on Thursday February 18, 2010 @01:57PM (#1134926)
There is a small sentence at the bottom of the complaint that says they will amend if any qualifying picts / information is produced.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by dbz on Thursday February 18, 2010 @10:34AM (#1134337)
Everyone who even knew about the computer webcam spying should go to prison. The fact that this could have been used as spying for child pornography- should be treated as an attempt of attaining child pornography.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by Confusion on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:05PM (#1134614)
No it shouldn't. As long as there is no indication that there were sexual motives, than no accusations of sexual motives should be made. The invasion of our rights in the name of our children has gone far enough. You shouldn't gratuitously say anything that encourages child pornography hysteria. You are just saying it because it serves your point that these guys should be punished severely. However, not even these guys deserve to be branded as child pornographers if they aren't.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by anamax on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:15PM (#1134652)
> As long as there is no indication that there were sexual motives, than no accusations of sexual motives should be made.

That's not how child porn laws work.

Laws should always be enforced most harshly against govt agents and folks who actually advocate the laws in question.

Govt employment is not a right and if someone is unwilling to accept heightened scrutiny, they can work for someone who is willing to accomodate that preference.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by lambda on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:27PM (#1134682)
No, laws should be applied equally to everyone.

You should not be punished more harshly because you are a "government agent." What does your postal clerk have to do with some idiot congressman who passed too strict a law on child porn?

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by wtallis on Thursday February 18, 2010 @01:31PM (#1134855)
Postal workers shouldn't necessarily be blamed for pornography laws, but that doesn't mean government agents should be treated equally.

Highway patrol officers who break traffic laws without using lights and sirens should be punished more severely than a first-time offender who is a normal citizen. Cops who abuse their power need to serve prison time.

With great power comes great responsibility.

We give our public school teachers a lot of power over the lives of our kids, by entrusting our kids to them for several hours a day. If they abuse the public trust, the potential for damage is much higher, and the punishment should be correspondingly more severe.

If we let our schools enact zero-tolerance policies for punishing our kids, we have the right to enact zero-tolerance laws for them f*ing with our kids' lives.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by kelnos on Thursday February 18, 2010 @05:56PM (#1135597)
"If they abuse the public trust, the potential for damage is much higher, and the punishment should be correspondingly more severe."

I don't disagree, but that's not what the law says. Get it into a law, and then reality will match up with your belief.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by gridspy on Thursday February 18, 2010 @09:33PM (#1135999)
I hate to think what would happen to a police officer serving serious time in a normal prison.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by anamax on Thursday February 18, 2010 @05:08PM (#1135455)
Govt workers typically have great authority to impose things on other people. For example, school officials can suspend students.

If they're not up to being held to a higher standard, they're not up to having authority.

Plus, enforcing more harshly on them brings attention to bad laws.

Like I said, if they're unwilling to accept this, if they want to be treated like an ordinary citizen, they can quit govt work and become one. No one is forcing them to work for govt.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday February 20, 2010 @06:46PM (#1139735)
>Govt workers typically have great authority to impose things on other people. For example, school officials can suspend students.

Government workers generally don't exercise their own authority in these respects they apply the local rules and laws. I don't know how USA school boards run so I can't say for sure this is true in the school situation however.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by koepked on Thursday February 18, 2010 @05:51PM (#1135581)
Some government workers have great authority to impose things on people, but I don't know if I'd agree that it's typical.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by anamax on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:52PM (#1136227)
> Some government workers have great authority to impose things on people, but I don't know if I'd agree that it's typical.

Every paper-pusher can make your life a living hell. Every teacher and adminstrator can punish your kid. And, I haven't even mentioned police, DAs, judges, and folks who are supposed to exercise discretion.

Janitors and the equivalent are about the only govt employees who don't have considerable power. They're a small minority of govt workers.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by andrewcooke on Friday February 19, 2010 @07:15AM (#1136713)
the problem is not "government"; the problem is "power". it is power that is being abused. whether that power comes through the government, or through other means is largely irrelevant.

i wish americans would understand this. that they don't means that abuses of power are treated in two completely different ways here. if it's the government, it's bad. if it's anything else (which typically means a private company) then it's "you shouldn't expect anything else you naive fool".

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by anamax on Friday February 19, 2010 @09:50AM (#1137015)
> the problem is not "government"; the problem is "power". it is power that is being abused. whether that power comes through the government, or through other means is largely irrelevant.

Except that it's not, because govt power is qualitatively different. A company can't throw you in jail. All that a company can do is refuse to deal with you.

> i wish americans would understand this.

I wish that non-Americans actually understood power.

Real power is when someone can do something to me or stop other people from dealing with me. It isn't when they refuse to deal with me.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by andrewcooke on Friday February 19, 2010 @10:00AM (#1137042)
you're still skewing things.

all that matters is power. the distinction you make above can easily be handled in terms of power: someone who can throw you in prison has more power over you than someone who cannot. restricting that to "government" adds blinders. for example, it takes the focus away from those that pay lobbyists to enact and enforce certain rules. by focussing on power and those that wield it you are freed from distortions like that.

it's no different to any other field: focussing on the abstract concept lets you handle more cases. talking about "oop" is often more useful than talking about "java"; focussing on "government" rather than "power" is the same mistake as confusing java with (all of) object oriented programming.

of course, java is (probably) the largest oo language, just as the us government is (probably) the largest source of power. but that doesn't stop the more abstract approach from being more useful.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by anamax on Friday February 19, 2010 @09:39PM (#1138522)
> all that matters is power. the distinction you make above can easily be handled in terms of power: someone who can throw you in prison has more power over you than someone who cannot. restricting that to "government" adds blinders.

Since the power to throw me into jail is restricted to govts ....

> of course, java is (probably) the largest oo language, just as the us government is (probably) the largest source of power. but that doesn't stop the more abstract approach from being more useful.

As I've shown, govt power is qualitativively different.

Moreover, you're trying to use "they have power too" to ignore govt power.

And, interestingly enough, almost all of the examples of corporate power are actually govt acting on behalf of govt. And yet, you seem to think that more govt, that ignoring govt power, will solve those problems....

Yes, abstractions are useful. Yours is an excuse to ignore the big power problems of the world.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by dnsworks on Thursday February 18, 2010 @01:24PM (#1134839)
Why? Crimes against government agents are prosecuted far more severely than crimes against the common man. If you rob a post office at gunpoint, it's a federal felony, with more extreme punishments than if you rob a corner store at gunpoint. The law singles out government employees as being more important than the common man in terms of protection.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by kelnos on Thursday February 18, 2010 @05:54PM (#1135593)
You've answered your own question. The law doesn't say government agents who engage in child pornography should be punished more severely than regular citizens. In the case of holding up a post office at gunpoint, it's not applying the law differently because the law is different.

FWIW, my understanding is that messing with the post in general is a federal crime. It has nothing to do with the government employee being more 'important' than the common man; that's just an unintended side effect.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by anamax on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:21PM (#1136172)
> The law doesn't say government agents who engage in child pornography should be punished more severely than regular citizens.

We know. We think that the law is wrong.

Note that DAs tend to give their fellow govt employees, especially police, a pass, so in practice the law is easier on govt employees. It's a trifecta of tribal, lobbying by govt employees, and "one hand washes the other".

> It has nothing to do with the government employee being more 'important' than the common man; that's just an unintended side effect.

Actually, it's quite intended. Look into the history of how those laws came about. They were lobbied for by govt employees.

And then there's the fact that DAs tend to go hard whenever a fellow govt employee is a victim. It's the same trifecta.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by Alex3917 on Thursday February 18, 2010 @10:30PM (#1136083)
"As long as there is no indication that there were sexual motives, than no accusations of sexual motives should be made."

I think the argument is that secretly videotaping children within their own homes is inherently sexual. And even if it isn't, this seems like a clear violation of Roe v Wade.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by tibbon on Thursday February 18, 2010 @09:29AM (#1134165)
Should set some interesting precedent. If this isn't child pornography, spying, unlawful wiretapping, etc... then I don't know what is.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by cgranade on Thursday February 18, 2010 @10:35AM (#1134338)
Given the role that schools have played in destroying the lives of some children by getting authorities involved in "sexting" cases, it would be especially ironic if this spying program produced child pornography charges. After all, in many cases, intent isn't required-- people have been arrested for having malware download child porn without the user's authorization or knowledge. Given that precedent, doing something like this and accidentally gathering child porn by taking an irresponsible and already likely illegal action would seem to be enough for the courts. Not being a lawyer, I don't know if this intuition is correct, but it would be an interesting precedent, no doubt.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by ErrantX on Thursday February 18, 2010 @10:41AM (#1134350)
> reople have been arrested for having malware download child porn without the user's authorization or knowledge

Do you have a citation for that, out of interest.

It's considered something of a myth within LE and I wasn't aware a case like that actually existed.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by aplusbi on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:09AM (#1134441)
Here is one such case: http://www.scmagazineus.com/malware-to-blame-for-porn-on-sta...

I also recall a case of a teacher whose school computer had malware that ended up displaying porn in the classroom who was arrested and faced up to 40 years in jail. I'm pretty sure she was acquitted.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by protomyth on Thursday February 18, 2010 @02:01PM (#1134935)
If I remember right, she was forced to give up her teacher's license.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by hga on Saturday February 20, 2010 @09:14AM (#1139003)
Search on teacher virus porn, e.g. http://www.daniweb.com/news/story219946.html

After the initial conviction was set aside, after 4 delays in sentencing, "[...] facing health problems, Amero pleaded guilty to one count of misdemeanor disorderly conduct, paying a $100 fine and losing her teaching license, just to settle the case."

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by ErrantX on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:25AM (#1134500)
Interesting. Do you know how/if I can get hold of the court documents relating to that?
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by cgranade on Thursday February 18, 2010 @10:49AM (#1134372)
Sadly, I don't have the citation off the top of my head. For all I know, I could've fallen for an urban legend. If I have, sorry for being gullible!
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by ErrantX on Thursday February 18, 2010 @10:54AM (#1134389)
It's cool - I do believe you. [You'll always get suspicion over that story because it is the #1 most common defence (and ironically easy to disprove)]

I'd always be interested to see if it actually happened though - it would be useful research.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by cx01 on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:52AM (#1134576)
How is it easy to disprove? The trojan could delete itself after downloading CP. Should be impossible to reconstruct what happened exactly.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by ErrantX on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:03PM (#1134604)
Of course there is an upper limit to how provable it is. But that is fairly elaborate malware your describing (because if that is all it did it should be fairly apparent - it also has to fake fairly extensive use as well).

Mostly it is very easy to see the CP activity (dont forget were not just talking about images on the HDD here but actual activity indicative of behavior). If it were downloaded all together, with no references in, say, web history etc, no thumbnails and nothing in the cache files (which are FULL of rich information) then it would ring alarm bells :)

Eventually even the most elaborate malware will make a mistake with activity that is not "normal" - and the investigation is intensive enough to pick this up.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by cx01 on Thursday February 18, 2010 @12:26PM (#1134677)
I don't think it would be hard. Just create a Windows application that hosts an IE ActiveX control and hides its main window. Or even better: When the user's screen saver is running, start a full-blown IE window and control it through Window messages. The traces would be identical to the case in which the user used IE himself.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by olliesaunders on Thursday February 18, 2010 @03:44PM (#1135227)
Since when did surveillance == pornography? Is CCTV pornography? This story isn't even about pornography. Why are we talking about pornography?!
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by electromagnetic on Thursday February 18, 2010 @11:17PM (#1136166)
I believe it's because you basically handed a remotely activated camera to a teenager in the implicit knowledge that said remotely activated camera will be taken into the teenagers room where they're going to at some point be naked.

Placing a camera in someone's room is akin to placing it in a bathroom, because at some point someone's getting naked and how a group of adults didn't comprehend this speaks worlds about the quality of education provided by the school in question.

There's also the very concerning matter that 50% of the students are likely male, and ~90% of males access porn through the internet. This means that 45% of students likely used this computer to look at porn, which likely means at some point 45% of the students had their penis' out in front of the laptop in question, which has a remotely activated camera on it. This isn't even discussing the 1/3 of women who access porn via the internet. This isn't even discussing the fact that a percentage of these students likely used the cameras for video-sex with their partners (personal experience on that one).

I'm sorry this is either gross ignorance that should be as severely punished as possible or it's exactly as bad as this thread of comments has taken it, and it should be as severely punished as possible. Regardless the potential was there to use the system for child pornography, and if there are no records that any compromising pictures were taken, then the school and its board members got exceptionally lucky.

Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by andrewcooke on Thursday February 18, 2010 @03:53PM (#1135253)
because child porn laws - or at least the perception of them - have become so disconnected from basic ideas like victim and intention that they appear completely arbitrary, associated with little more than unauthorised pictures of minors.
Re:School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at scho... by Daniel_Newby on Friday February 19, 2010 @04:23AM (#1136519)
"Since when did surveillance == pornography?"

Since the camera was issued to accompany the student throughout their daily life: bedroom, changing the diaper of a toddler they are babysitting, bathroom, etc.