IntelliJ absolutely trounces VSS and some combination of Spring Boot, DropWizard or Vert.x blows ASP.NET MVC away. Not to mention the whole ecosystem is a hell of a lot more open. There is a library for just about anything under the sun.
It gets even worse on desktops, as sysadmins might be able to isolate a server enough to allow some "new" tech, but vetting a new Java version or library for a few thousand office desktops is a task nobody really wants to do. So I wouldn't be surprised to still see some Java 1.4 Swing apps in use at big insurance or pharma companies. (And if I'd had to pick between that or do a web app that supports their IE8 browsers…)
The same thing applies to many other software packages, including browsers, Linux and Spring. Sane IA folks don't like to deploy known security holes.
It sounds like you're dealing with some backwards-thinking folk. ;-)
The alternative is auditing all your installed software packages with Java dependencies. Re-hire the agency that did that small Swing client 8 years ago. Hire someone completely new to reverse engineer another client because the original company went belly up. Ad infinitum, ad nauseam.
No wonder they'll do software cryonics.
This is getting better slightly in recent years, when you no longer have that many desktop clients and utilities, as upgrading servers is way easier than building new default images for all your desktop clients.