News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb

Remember the days before Airbnb when their biz idea would have been laughed at? There are LAWS against renting out your apartment. In 2016 I think the world is ready for local.menu, the app that lets you rent out your kitchen to a restaurant for a night, your restaurant. i.e. you are allowed to cook for people in your neighborhood with no health permit / zoning laws issues.

It's very simple. A mom is cooking dinner for 4. She posts to local.menu what she is making and sets a 5 min time limit. She gets 3 hits in 5 mins of people close by that want an extra serving of what she is making. They come by her house/apt and get their food to go. The mom simply made 3 extra servings of what she was making for her family anyways. And the markup is crazy. She can sell her special curry for $30 a plate to hipsters that want good curry, local, and fast.

Go ahead. Tell me this will never work because it breaks some laws.

( 22 comments | 2 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by altotrees on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:11PM (#11338597)
Being a single person who does not cook often, this would be a fantastic idea to see come to fruition.

On the other hand, as a person who skews toward the overly-cautious, I would be concerned about the lack of sanitation inspections, servsafe certifications and other safeguards that commercial kitchens adhere to. Also, how could you be assured that Mom is not in a dire financial situation, re-heating her special curry to sell at a marked-up price - a special curry that went bad several days ago.

Law-, permit- and zoning-wise, I am not sure of what would need to be done. It is an interesting idea for sure, albeit one that would take some serious planning.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:27AM (#11353554)
i think giving out 5 star ratings just like uber would help u find the good places. People are people. We live in a big village. Let's all eat together :)
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by pacnw on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:17PM (#11333972)
There are a bunch of these already, exactly as you described it.
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by yeukhon on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:43PM (#11334286)
His idea is very different from gobble.com or others. This is a family/home-made kitchen idea, which is very very common in Asiaa countries like.
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:17PM (#11333976)
links please.
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by pacnw on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:22PM (#11333995)
gobble.com, mytable.com, josephine.com...

gobble seems to have pivoted to delivering ingredients, which differs from their initial plan from 2011: http://www.treehugger.com/green-food/gobble-helps-you-order-...

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:26PM (#11334017)
oh! you are totally right! haha, thanks. I'm gonna use one of these vs. build this :)
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:15PM (#11333960)
You seriously think health standards for restaurants is something that needs to be disrupted?
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by yeukhon on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:41PM (#11334278)
1. A lot of people make homemade food, so what's up with the health and hygiene standard there?

2. If you think health and hygiene standard in restaurants are good, I don't know what else to say but many restaurants receive C or lower grade in NY. Some due to discrimination, some due to misjudgement, but many do reflect serious lack of proper maintenance and cleaning.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:59PM (#11334333)
Home made food is explicitly that - for your own home. You are already responsible for the people you're feeding.

Once it becomes about making money without regulation, I guaran-fucking-tee you there will be people using it to run a "business" with zero fucks given about food safety.

Sure there are restaurants with a low rating. There are also the ones that have been shut down. That's the sort of place you need to be worried about

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:35AM (#11336875)
but that's 0.001% of the people cooking. The rest are making nice food I wanna eat!
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:34PM (#11337755)
> but that's 0.001% of the people cooking

What are you basing that number on?

Once someone starts using the system to make money, a number of important dynamics change.

- they need to start buying more products, with the intent of making a profit, so there is even more incentive for them to buy "discount" items that are marked down due to being close to their use-by date. Risk goes up.

- they need to store a lot more products. How many home kitchens do you know of that have different fridges to completely separate raw meat from cooked meat, dairy, etc?

- they need to have a way to keep the prepared food ready to 'serve' once it's been prepared/cooked. How many home kitchens do you know that can keep prepared food easy/quick to serve and hygienic at the same time?

Your idea is no more about "sharing economy" than Uber is. They're both just saying "who needs accreditation, licences or insurance - any schmoe can do this".

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:17PM (#11333974)
i seriously think people want curry and once this app takes off, laws will be re-defined because people don't want to lose this new thing they love. i.e. uber/airbnb/zenefits
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:53AM (#11334485)
Can you elaborate how people wanting curry equates to disregarding food safety laws?
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:34AM (#11336866)
airbnb: people wanting cheap hotel rooms equates to disregarding hotel zoning laws

uber: people wanting on-demand taxi service equates to disregarding taxi medalian laws

local.menu: people wanting curry next door equates to disregarding "selling" food laws.

i.e. once people start using the new things that break laws and love them, they collectively go, f those laws they were dumb.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:53AM (#11337013)
> once people start using the new things that break laws and love them, they collectively go, f those laws they were dumb.

People collectively say a lot of things, that doesn't make them true or accurate.

Americans in particular seem to have an obsession with "fuck regulations, free market ftw" - plenty of other countries regulate things that make sense, without making things overly burdensome.

Go ask anyone who had a mortgage and/or pension fund in 2008 how that free market thing turned out for them.

> people wanting curry next door

I don't know what your obsession with curry is specifically, but if it's next door, they're your neighbour. Just ask them if you can have some fucking curry.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:17PM (#11338101)
you have a point about not all regulations are bad. But this one seems like airbnb bad, not mortgage2008 bad.

s/curry/anyfood

Asking your neighbour is not the same thing as letting cooks broadcast what they are cooking and if they are willing to sell plates.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:29PM (#11338226)
> But this one seems like airbnb bad, not mortgage2008 bad.

This one is Airbnb bad if you assume that 1 out of every 5 Airbnb rentals is being used to (take your pick) shoot porn; murder and cut up the bodies of people (to later be fed to pigs); arrange a reboot of the Bumfights video series; run a 24-hour needle swapping joint; etc

> Asking your neighbour is not the same thing as letting cooks broadcast what they are cooking and if they are willing to sell plates.

Exactly. The first one is a social interaction. The second is a business, and that's my whole point.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:08PM (#11333931)
also think about a big apartment building. What if 1 person was the "cook" for that village? Isn't that better, more social. human like, than each human alone in their own apt eating a tv dinner?
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:56AM (#11334498)
Why is the choice between everyone eating from a sole cook or everyone eating TV dinners?

I don't think I'll ever understand American culture.

Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by andrewfromx on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:37AM (#11336887)
big american apartment building can be very lonely and isolating. No one talks to anyone. You goto work, u go home, u interact only with your tv. Bringing back the concept of a village where people gather around and eat together is a good thing.
Re:Ask HN: Critique my biz idea – local.menu the next Airbnb by stephenr on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:37PM (#11337766)
> big american apartment building can be very lonely and isolating. No one talks to anyone. You goto work, u go home, u interact only with your tv.

Do you see the irony of the situation - you're complaining about a lack of social interaction and community - and your solution is an app and the transfer of money.