News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by whack on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:17PM (#11333703)
It's possible that you're one of the unlucky people who falls into the combination you described above. Unfortunately, even the best system currently available will often have cracks, and you seem to have found the one that currently exists. The vast majority of the time, kids with rich parents have a substantially blessed childhood & family-support, which justifies them having to pay substantially more in tuition fees.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by jqgatsby on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:44PM (#11333820)
Sorry, what you call a 'crack in the best system available' is the life I've had to live. I've had to take less societally-beneficial jobs because they paid more, while my loan-free friends were off joining the Peace Corps or teaching. I think the world is made a worse place when people like me are turned into mercenaries.

MIT thinks it's okay to boil down someone's financial future into a single dominant number (parental income). What if your parents had a lot of debt because of a major illness or death? What if that supposedly high income is counter-balanced by living somewhere expensive because that's where the high-paying jobs are? The fact that none of that is taken into account means it's not about bad luck, it's about an unjust system.

MIT could afford to make tuition free, but the popular misconception that they're levying a tax on the rich means they won't. If you want to control how much one generation passes on to the next, there are far better mechanisms to do that than college tuition.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by massysett on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @09:39AM (#11336440)
You take no responsibility for your situation. You talk like MIT just happened to you. You turned yourself into a mercenary by attending MIT and accumulating the debt with full knowledge that you would take high-paying jobs to pay it off-jobs that you could get thanks to your MIT credential.

Once your debt is paid off you will have one less excuse to go do whatever it is you claim you really want to do. The only question is whether you will actually take advantage of that or whether you continue to whine about the world of opportunities that were somehow foisted upon you when you willingly chose to attend MIT.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by jqgatsby on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @08:16PM (#11386048)
I willingly took the best deal I could get, and I would make the same deal with the information I have today. At the same time, a system that arbitrarily indebts some students and gives others a free ride is unfair and needs to change. Also, I think calling my position whining is a pretty low level of discourse.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by vecter on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:07PM (#11334170)
How could MIT sustainably afford to make tuition free? Genuine question. That's a pretty bold assertion.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by tanker on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:27PM (#11338205)
That's an interesting problem.

I have a few ideas 1) Replace tuition with taking x% of income for y years following graduation. I'm not sure how this would work in regards to low-income degrees / departments. For example, would the low return on investment for an arts department mean it would get less funding? I suppose this would cause universities to optimize their education for earning potential of graduates. Could have interesting effects. Not all beneficial.

2) Could they use their endowments to essentially provide interest free loans? I'm guessing their would be lots of problems with this that I can't see.

3) You pay nothing while in school, but you pay a straightforward fraction of the school's operating costs for the next x years. I like this concept. If you make x long enough, your graduates have an interest in ensuring future students are able to contribute to the cause. Of course, they also have an interest in keeping costs low. That could create poor dynamics. Improvements would have to come from donations, not be a part of the budget.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by jon-wood on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:34PM (#11338265)
Presumably using the proceeds of the hedge fund they're running on the side.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by vecter on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:25PM (#11338701)
Have you actually done the math to show this works out in the long run?
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by jqgatsby on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @07:54PM (#11385933)
http://web.mit.edu/facts/financial.html

In 2015, tuition accounted for only 10% of MIT's yearly revenue (~$331M), so you have to cut the rest of the budget by 10% to give everyone free tuition.

One natural area to focus on is yearly administrative costs, which in 2015 were $763M.

If you gradually cut administrative costs by building fewer beautiful buildings for undergraduates to be indebted in or hiring fewer administrators, you can afford for every undergraduate to attend tuition free.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by amluto on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:27PM (#11333748)
I tend to dislike systems of the form "if you make/own less than $X, you get $Y benefit". It often leads to nasty non-monotonic outcomes and like this.

For actual public benefits, I'd much prefer to give all the benefits to all the people and raise taxes accordingly. This means that, as a CA resident, I think I should be permitted to deduct rent even if my AGI is $38,259, and I think I should get the full Affordable Care Act subsidy regardless of my income. The rules would be simpler and my taxes would be simpler. In exchange, I would gladly pay higher taxes to make up the deficit.

For public university, it's a bit messier because of state residency rules. And for private universities, this wouldn't work at all unless the government directly subsidized private education.

(But maybe the government should ditch all the complicated student aid and student loan benefits and offer a blanket subsidy for education at accredited universities.)

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by _delirium on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:08PM (#11333925)
The universities I know of that have free-tuition programs do phase them out gradually, to try to avoid too much weirdness that would come from a hard threshold. For example, Harvard charges no tuition to students from households making under $65,000, but above $65,000 tuition phases in slowly, reaching full tuition only at $150,000+.

However I do agree your proposed solution is better. Have universalist public programs that everyone can take advantage of regardless of income (tuition-free public university, no-charge public healthcare, etc.), and then instead of mucking with means-tested benefits and aid phase-outs as a way of indirectly taxing the rich, just tax them through actual taxes, the old-fashioned way.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by Domenic_S on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:12PM (#11337578)
> above $65,000 tuition phases in slowly, reaching full tuition only at $150,000+

Which is still silly. Who has more to spend/better opportunity to save? Two parents that make $75k each in Mountain View or 1 parent who makes $64,500 in Nowhere, Indiana?

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by fovc on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @08:39AM (#11336029)
There was an article recently where Finland was considering something along those lines. [1] is all I was able to find quickly:

> The Finnish government, elected earlier this year, is planning to introduce a tax-free monthly payment of 800 euros ($865) to all adult Finns, regardless of income, wealth or employment status. The payment would replace most other state benefits.

[1] http://money.cnn.com/2015/12/07/news/economy/finland-basic-i...

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by wildmusings on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:33PM (#11333776)
Throwing more free money at universities will just make things worse.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by jimbokun on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:17PM (#11333969)
"I think I should get the full Affordable Care Act subsidy regardless of my income"

I appreciate your sentiment, but you realize all of the insurance companies will just raise their rates by the amount of the subsidy, right? More demand in the form of government money earmarked for a specific good, with the same supply of the good, means higher prices.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by dangrossman on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:26PM (#11334015)
> you realize... right?

Gosh, I really dislike that turn of phrase.

Anyway, they can't do that, since the ACA has mandated that insurers spend at least 80 or 85% of premiums on health care costs since 2012.

The insurers ride that line as closely as possible, since their profit has to come out of the 15% allowed margin. This means an increase in total premiums without a commensurate increase in the cost of claims cannot happen. If an insurer's payouts don't exceed the mandated Medical Loss Ratio, they have to refund their insured customers for the difference by mailing out rebate checks. I've received two such checks myself.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by koolba on Monday March 21, 2016 @10:41PM (#11334071)
> Anyway, they can't do that, since the ACA has mandated that insurers spend at least 80 or 85% of premiums on health care costs since 2012.

That part of the law is particularly terrible. It directly incentivizes keeping costs high as the profit of the insurer is a fixed (says max but that means exactly 15%) percentage of the gross. It's in their interests to have the price of everything go up!

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by Grishnakh on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:27PM (#11334234)
The whole law is terrible and it should be repealed and replaced with a nationalized system. As long as you have the insurance companies acting as middlemen, it's in their best interest to deny care as much as possible, to increase their profit. What actual good do they do? None, they just come between the patient and the caregiver.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by dangrossman on Monday March 21, 2016 @11:41PM (#11334280)
> it's in their best interest to deny care as much as possible, to increase their profit

That's not the case, as the comment you replied to points out.

Let's say an insurer collects $1B in premiums some year. The ACA mandates that at least 85% of that is spent on healthcare costs. At most, the company gets to keep $150M, or 15% of the premiums. For every claim denied bringing the payouts below $850M, the number they keep 15% of goes down, so their profits go down. Denying claims costs them money, rather than letting them keep more.

If the insurer wants to make more than $150M the next year, there is only one way to do that: pay more than $850M in healthcare costs this time, and increase premiums by the same amount. That means encouraging and approving more claims, not fewer.

Unfortunately, this aspect of the MLR promotes, rather than punishes, increased healthcare costs as a byproduct. Competition is supposed to be the check on that -- if an insurer doesn't control costs so that it can raise premiums and keep 15% of a bigger number, you'll switch to a plan with another insurer that isn't doing that and offers lower premiums. Unfortunately, that's not doing the job very well for a variety of reasons.

> What actual good do they do? None, they just come between the patient and the caregiver.

Insurance protects the insured from catastrophic losses by pooling risk. When the caregiver wants to bill me several hundred thousand dollars in unavoidable expenses, I very much appreciate having a middleman I only pay $200 per month to instead.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by Grishnakh on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @10:48AM (#11336972)
For your point 1, that's just splitting hairs. It's in the insurer's interest to increase profits, rather than to provide care. So you just pointed out a way they found of increasing profits, which results in both ballooned healthcare costs and increased premiums all around. This isn't helping me get high-quality healthcare at affordable prices.

For your point 2, you protect people from catastrophic losses by having a single payer: the government. Insurance is supposed to be a way of protecting people from catastrophic losses, which is why we have it for house fires, car accidents/thefts, etc. Healthcare is not about catastrophic losses in most cases, it's about ongoing care to maintain health. You getting your yearly checkup at the doctor is not a "catastrophic loss", nor is you getting an ultrasoound to check out something the doctor found to make sure it isn't something really bad. These are just ongoing care, and it isn't what insurance is designed to handle fundamentally.

As for $200/month, I wish. More like $800/month.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by jimbokun on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @09:22AM (#11336331)
"Gosh, I really dislike that turn of phrase."

Point taken.

Maybe:

"I appreciate your sentiment, but won't that result in insurance companies raising their rates by the amount of the subsidy?"

I think that reads better. Makes the same point, less argumentative.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by cmdrfred on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @08:31AM (#11335976)
Remember profit is a funny thing. If I own a company and I net after taxes 100 million a year and then pay myself 75 million in compensation I can claim that my company only makes 25 million a year.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by shkkmo on Monday March 21, 2016 @09:40PM (#11333805)
> The vast majority of the time, kids with rich parents have a substantially blessed childhood & family-support, which justifies them having to pay substantially more in tuition fees.

How does it justify that? We want to punish them with debt because their parents might have provided them with some opportunities?

The current system of funding higher education penalizes children of parents who don't prioritize college. There is no point to this and it just helps perpetuate privilege. We should stop unfairly assuming that parents are willing and able to pay for college.

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by lmm on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:54AM (#11335404)
We have a limited amount of subsidy to allocate where it will do the most good. Most of the time the children of rich parents - even those who had little interest in college - have more advantages overall than even a fully subsidized poor student would have. So it makes sense to focus our subsidy on those poor students.
Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by Domenic_S on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:26PM (#11337686)
Rich parents? Hilarious. You way overestimate where the line is drawn. When I went to UCD, my parents' income was ~$70k (in California) and I got some subsidized loans, then mostly unsubsidized loans, then they made my parents take out PLUS loans in their own names (more accurately, they capped the amount of loans I could take personally and the only way to make up the delta is either family cash contribution, or parent PLUS loans). Except for a small amount of interest subsidy, I got $0 financial assistance.

Now, my own personal situation is a deal of my own making -- I decided to sign on the dotted line. But in the aggregate, considering all the other students like me --- I'm actually shocked at the push back in this thread. The same group of people that bemoans the death of the middle class can't see how this is a part of the problem?

I feel lucky. I was in one of the last generations to get halfway-decent interest rates. My younger brother is paying through the nose (what is it now, 6-7%?).

Re:Universities Are Becoming Billion-Dollar Hedge Funds with... by lmm on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @06:41PM (#11340512)
Yeah, 70k is well into rich territory. What's the median income again?