Re:3 Tesla Execs Dead In Palo Alto Plane Crash
by neurotech1 on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @04:39PM
(#1132675)
You are likely correct on most of that, except that the cirrus chute is good down to 500 ft.
That said, there are other systems that can help in accidents like this. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TAWS
Another option is NavFLIR / EVS which is basically a IR camera to give enhanced visibility during bad weather.
If they did have an engine failure after take-off, NavFLIR could have aided a forced landing. The cause of this crash are not yet known.
Feel free to email me if you want.
Re:3 Tesla Execs Dead In Palo Alto Plane Crash
by paulgerhardt on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @10:15PM
(#1133311)
I was looking through the FAA AAI site (http://www.faa.gov/data_research/accident_incident/prelimina...) and apparently there was an incident just a week and half ago involving a Cirrus colliding with a glider tow-rope/tow-plane at 8,000ft (about 2,500ft AGL in Boulder).
This is the first time I'd seen video footage of the Cirrus shoot deployed in a non-simulation environment. Unfortunately only those onboard the glider survived.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/02/06/boulder-air-collisi... (video at bottom.)
From the limited amount of technical details available, I would guess that a combination of the two happened here.
While small duel engine aircraft may be able to sustain cruising altitude under significant strain on one engine, they are notorious for not being able to climb, and particular take off with only half power - certainly not with 3 people and baggage.
This is speculation, but by the looks of the location of the crash, and given that Palo Alto airport has a left hand pattern on runway 31 (that is, they fly counter-clockwise around the airport after taking off in the magnetic direction of 310 degrees) they most likely experienced a power failure during or very shortly after take off on one engine (but maybe both) and attempted to turn back to the airport to land. Interestingly +100ft transmission towers east of the airport are mentioned in FAA notices. These may or may not refer to the ~200ft power lines in the neighborhood. Without of a power failure they should have been +500ft before turning crosswind.
http://maps.google.com/maps/ms?hl=en&ie=UTF8&msa=0&#...
The reality of the situation is that, like medicine, reactive measures like Bailout mechanisms will always be less successful than preventive treatments which maintain good health, here in the form of thorough annual maintenances, preflight inspections, and run-ups (testing the full operation of the engine before leaving the ground.)