Re:A chilling mathematical model of inequality
by hnhg on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:52PM
(#11324105)
Yes, but are these any simpler than most written discussions of the same topics, in things like essays? It seems that the once they're codified in some kind of mathematical model then we can see the shortcomings right away, whereas an essay might obfuscate this, and yet be conceptually even weaker.
In another way, the same arguments could be made in a mathematical model and an essay, but the model might just be easier to criticise. I'd say that's a good thing.
1. The good is a commodity, i.e. its labeling has no effect on perceived value
2. The selling firms are perfectly competitive (i.e., no partial or complete monopolies that allow price-fixing)
3. The buyers are perfectly competitive (i.e., no purchasing groups)
4. All sellers can sell to all buyers equally easily
5. All parties in the market have equal access to information
6. All parties act rationally and based only on the marginal utility of each individual transaction
etc., etc., and a whole litany of other things that we know are rarely true. Since the theory is so "squishy" in practice, one could even protest that it does more harm than good when treated as a de facto starting point for price modeling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supply_and_demand#Criticisms
So this model, even if it too is sadly oversimplified, may still be useful simply by starting from a different set of assumptions than whatever is typical in the field, and seeing how the modeled behavior differs from existing theories. There's basically no hope of experimental validation for any of this, though.