Re:School grades are hopelessly broken
by tokenadult on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @02:08PM
(#1132203)
If you failed a test designed for average people, then by that criteria, you are below average.
There are numerous counterexamples to this in the gifted education literature. If a teacher writes a test without fact-checking the approved answers, it is possible for a child who has a better grasp of the facts than the teacher to get a bad score on the test, while a child who parrots the teacher's mistaken view of the facts gets a good score.
The system actually lets down all learners, above-average, average, and below-average, but that's not only in the form of lousy grading standards. For detailed references to this, see the books
There are more articles on similar subjects showing that much school improvement is necessary.
P.S. It may be you are not a native speaker of English, or you are a native speaker of English like me who types rapidly under conditions of distraction. I just wanted to point out, in a way that I hope will be friendly, that "criteria" is the plural of "criterion," so one can write of "that criterion" (singular) or "those criteria" (plural) as occasion demands.
There are numerous counterexamples to this in the gifted education literature. If a teacher writes a test without fact-checking the approved answers, it is possible for a child who has a better grasp of the facts than the teacher to get a bad score on the test, while a child who parrots the teacher's mistaken view of the facts gets a good score.
The system actually lets down all learners, above-average, average, and below-average, but that's not only in the form of lousy grading standards. For detailed references to this, see the books
http://books.google.com/books?id=EjkKBotJcyIC&dq=Knowing...
and
http://books.google.com/books?id=7ncMKDdCd84C&printsec=f...
and the articles
http://archive.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/fall99...
and
http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf
and
http://archive.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/issues...
There are more articles on similar subjects showing that much school improvement is necessary.
P.S. It may be you are not a native speaker of English, or you are a native speaker of English like me who types rapidly under conditions of distraction. I just wanted to point out, in a way that I hope will be friendly, that "criteria" is the plural of "criterion," so one can write of "that criterion" (singular) or "those criteria" (plural) as occasion demands.