News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:53PM (#11321580)
Because the only remaining reason to deploy DNSSEC is to exploit DANE to allow SMTP MTAs to force TLS. All the other uses of DNSSEC are already DOA.

It's a little tricky to explain why this is the case without getting into a lot of gritty detail. A shorthand answer is that browser vendors have, pretty much as a group, decided not to adopt DANE (the DNSSEC-based alternative to the X.509 CA system), and DANE is the only reason anyone cares about DNS security on an Internet where everything is going to be encrypted (usually with TLS) by default.

Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by colanderman on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:01PM (#11321603)
Is SSHFP not a legitimate use case for DNSSEC? (Genuinely curious.)
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:43AM (#11321845)
No, SSHFP is pretty silly as a motivating use case for DNSSEC. There's nothing it does that you can't do (better!) with some other system. It makes sense if you already have a secure DNS. But that begs the question of why you would need a secure DNS.

You don't need a secure DNS for the web.

You don't, with STS deployed, need a secure DNS for email.

Is publishing SSH key fingerprints so important that we should do a forklift upgrade of the DNS? No, of course not.

Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by AndyMcConachie on Sunday March 20, 2016 @08:37AM (#11322688)
STS information is stored in DNS records. Why would you not want to secure those?

Also, I think you're underestimating the growth of DNSSEC deployments. I've been watching DNSSEC growth for about 2 years and it is steadily moving up and to the right.

Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2016 @11:14AM (#11323229)
It has taken two decades to get to this point. The protocol has been substantially revised four times, and, after each of those four revisions, DNSSEC proponents said "now, we've got it right, and it's ready for universal deployment".

It is nowhere near ready for universal deployment today, and, indeed, virtually nobody relies on it, unlike TLS.

Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by AndyMcConachie on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:07PM (#11323401)
DNSSEC ain't pretty. I'll agree with you there, but that doesn't mean it isn't the best thing going for us in terms of securing the DNS. Like it or not it's important to be able to trust DNS responses.

I guess I don't have some expectation that deployment should take place quickly. Or that the first go at a protocol is going to always get it right. Just because a journey is difficult doesn't mean the journey isn't worth taking.

DNSSEC and TLS are unrelated. They're trying to solve different problems.

Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:31PM (#11323506)
There is no point to securing the DNS. There are only downsides.
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by yuhong on Sunday March 20, 2016 @01:42PM (#11323803)
*using DNSSEC
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:21PM (#11324473)
I don't think there's any point to securing the DNS at all.
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by stephenr on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:09AM (#11321765)
It absolutely is a legitimate use case, and would IMO improve security for the type of developers who do use SSH, but don't know what a fingerprint is. It would also make it easier to create secure connections for non-developers, e.g. a SFTP/SCP based file sync app.
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by AndyMcConachie on Sunday March 20, 2016 @08:34AM (#11322682)
DNSSEC adoption is actually doing pretty well. And there are reasons beyond DANE to deploy it.
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2016 @11:12AM (#11323221)
Please share.
Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by AndyMcConachie on Sunday March 20, 2016 @12:16PM (#11323446)
I don't have good numbers for signing of zones. Although we do know that these numbers are increasing. Cloudflare recently turned on DNSSEC for all of their clients.

Geoff Huston at APNIC does some good work at measuring validation. Check out slide 2 and 24 of this preso. https://meetings.icann.org/en/marrakech55/schedule/wed-dnsse...

Again, I'm not arguing that DNSSEC adoption has been easy and fast. But it's being adopted steadily.

Re:Internet Draft: SMTP Strict Transport Security by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2016 @01:50PM (#11323831)
No, I'm asking about the reasons to deploy it.