News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by grinich on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @01:33PM (#1132094)
On the topic of grade inflation:

In 1966, 22% of Harvard undergraduate students earned A's. By 1996, that figure rose to 46%. That same year, 82% of Harvard seniors graduated with honors.

In 1973, 31% of all grades at Princeton were A's. By 1997 that rose to 43%. In 1997, only 12% of all grades given at Princeton were below the B range.

(source: Source: American Academy of Arts & Sciences)

One of the best things about MIT is that they have not succumbed to the this trend. There is no such thing as "honors"— An MIT degree is an honor by itself. That attitude is a fundamental basis of the student culture.

Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by jbeda on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @02:10PM (#1132212)
The data from http://gradeinflation.com/ (posted in another response) suggests that MIT is worse than average for grade inflation.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by hga on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @04:49PM (#1132723)
A thought: In the period from 1980 or earlier to the dot.com crash, ~ 400 students in each MIT class were majors in the EECS department ("Course 6"). With a class size of ~ 1050, that's 38% of the students.

In the early '80s EECS drastically changed it's core curriculum (or at least the CS part of it, SICP/6.001 was the start), and it definitely got better at teaching it.

If that also gave the students a better foundation for higher level courses, then we'd expect significant grade inflation based on MIT's policy of grading on mastery instead of the curve.

Also during that period the EE to CS ratio was 3:1 and flipped to a mirror 1:3. If CS is better or markedly better taught ... and be sure to factor in higher availability of computers, before MIT and at MIT ... that probably also is a factor.

Assume also during this period that only half the majors had a "calling" to EECS; therefore the quality of teaching would make the most difference to the other half to whom it doesn't come so naturally.

Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by jbeda on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @05:03PM (#1132750)
The source doesn't break out EECS from the rest of MIT. To be fair, though, this looks to be really long term data. If you dig into the numbers (http://gradeinflation.com/MIT.html) things look a lot more steady over the last 30 years. It looks like there was significant inflation through the 1960s but it flattened out since then.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by hga on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @05:09PM (#1132764)
It's very important to look at the time series, for the '60s were a special case of giving (male) students high enough grades so that they wouldn't flunk out and become eligible for the draft and service in Vietnam. I don't know about MIT's history of grading in that period, but I wouldn't be surprised if that happened.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by grinich on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @07:56PM (#1133114)
In looking at MIT, it's important to note that they grade on a 5.0 scale. I'm assuming these are readjusted, but its not stated anywhere.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by sp332 on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @01:50PM (#1132142)
My college didn't do grade inflation either. If you do an average job, you get a C. At the beginning of each year, they call the parents of incoming students and tell them not to be worried if the students get Cs - most people in the college get Cs. The on-campus bookstore sold t-shirts with "C+ Better than average!" on them.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by hga on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @01:56PM (#1132163)
Well, I'd say it's an aspect of one of the best things, that MIT is firmly dedicated to meritocracy. If you belong in your department (and there is at least one for you) and put in the work, you'll get As and Bs and the degree at the end.

A reflection of this is that you are allowed a "saving throw" in your final semester: you can petition to graduate if you are lacking just one required course that you earned an F in that last semester. It must be "well earned", you have to have really tried, and I don't know how often the petition is granted but it is upon occasion.

Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by chrischen on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @01:59PM (#1132172)
Do they have legacy admissions?
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by tedunangst on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @02:26PM (#1132262)
The internet says yes and no, and I'd guess (without further information) the correct situation is closest to the "no bonus points for legacy, but you get a second look before rejection" policy one source claimed.
Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by hga on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @02:47PM (#1132349)
Yes, from the inside what I've heard is that it's no more than a "second look". Everyone who attends MIT must pass 1 year each (and at a fast pace) of the calculus (first term equals the AP Calculus BC curriculum) and classical mechanics and E&M (one term each). Plus one term of serious chemistry and nowadays I think one of biology.

MIT doesn't accept anyone who they don't think can make it. This works in part because of the self selection in applicants, although nowadays they're getting 13,000 per year, 1/3 of which the Admissions Office judges can do the work.

Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by rflrob on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @04:29PM (#1132644)
"MIT doesn't accept anyone who they don't think can make it. This works in part because of the self selection in applicants, although nowadays they're getting 13,000 per year, 1/3 of which the Admissions Office judges can do the work."

If you think about it though, for an incoming class size of about 1000, they're still rejecting 3/4ths of the qualified applicants. Assuming a legacy applicant is qualified (and I'd suspect for a number of reasons that they're more likely to be qualified than the median applicant), that second look can be a big benefit.

Re:School grades are hopelessly broken by hga on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @05:01PM (#1132744)
Arrgh ... it's not 1/3, it's around 3,000. But your point still stands, they're rejecting 2/3rds of the qualified applicants.