Re:Giving Up on TDD
by wpietri on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:41PM
(#11319812)
> But he doesn't. Because the benefits aren't higher, in fact they are lower (as is the case with every well-intended scheme in the history of anything.)
The benefits of X are always lower than any naive adopter thinks? That's quite a claim. Would you care to justify that? Heck, don't even worry about the general case, just explain it for this one.
I've been doing TDD for many years at this point. Right now I'm working on a hobby project where I was intentionally sloppy about testing, just to see how little I could get away with. The answer is: in the long term, I can get away with surprisingly little. But there's a lot of subtlety in exactly how and when the benefits come, and when exactly sloppiness is ok.
Given that I'm still learning about the benefits of TDD despite many years of practice and thought, I'd say there's no reason to think a novice would have a particularly good idea. Maybe their expectations are unrealistically low, maybe high. But more likely it's both and neither. Maybe one's very notion of "benefit" changes over time. TDD has certainly done that for me.
The benefits of X are always lower than any naive adopter thinks? That's quite a claim. Would you care to justify that? Heck, don't even worry about the general case, just explain it for this one.
I've been doing TDD for many years at this point. Right now I'm working on a hobby project where I was intentionally sloppy about testing, just to see how little I could get away with. The answer is: in the long term, I can get away with surprisingly little. But there's a lot of subtlety in exactly how and when the benefits come, and when exactly sloppiness is ok.
Given that I'm still learning about the benefits of TDD despite many years of practice and thought, I'd say there's no reason to think a novice would have a particularly good idea. Maybe their expectations are unrealistically low, maybe high. But more likely it's both and neither. Maybe one's very notion of "benefit" changes over time. TDD has certainly done that for me.