News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 19, 2016 @01:20PM (#11319375)
> if inflation weren't bad for the little guy, we wouldn't have to raise the minimum wage periodically

How does that follow at all? Inflation means the value of money decreases, which means the price of things increase. The minimum wage is a price, so in order to keep it the same in real dollars it has to match inflation in nominal dollars.

> Read that carefully, and between the lines. One of the policy justifications for inflation is that it cheats the working class out of the value of their earnings, in the name of "employment".

You aren't being cheated out of anything. If tomorrow you're being paid the same amount but paying more for things and you don't like it, you can demand a raise or find another job. And if you can't do that, having some prices increase but not all prices is better for you than the alternative of taking a pay cut, because the pay cut reduces the amount of money you earn to pay for even the things that don't change in price, like a fixed rate mortgage payment.

Inflation is basically a tax on money. The people who pay it are the people who have money and the people who are owed money. You're trying to make the argument that future wages are money you'll be owed tomorrow and claim that inflation hurts the working class that way, but that is not the dominant effect, not least because most working class people do actually get cost of living increases.

Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by dnautics on Saturday March 19, 2016 @03:41PM (#11320093)
Let's parse this carefully:

> If tomorrow you're being paid the same amount but paying more for things and you don't like it, you can demand a raise or find another job.

The "you can demand a raise or find another job" argument. true for both the inflation case where your nominal pay stays the same and the the case where your nominal pay is cut.

> And if you can't do that, having some prices increase but not all prices is better for you than the alternative of taking a pay cut, because the pay cut reduces the amount of money you earn to pay for even the things that don't change in price, like a fixed rate mortgage payment.

Most poor people don't have a 'fixed rate mortgage payment', so your model of american poverty and the factors that influence their economic standard is delusional. Americans living on the margins are very much more concerned about things like the cost of food and fuel than mortgage payments.

Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:52PM (#11320861)
> The "you can demand a raise or find another job" argument. true for both the inflation case where your nominal pay stays the same and the the case where your nominal pay is cut.

What conclusion did you expect to follow from that?

> Most poor people don't have a 'fixed rate mortgage payment', so your model of american poverty and the factors that influence their economic standard is delusional. Americans living on the margins are very much more concerned about things like the cost of food and fuel than mortgage payments.

Let's start with a fact. A significant majority of American families own a home. Of that group, the ones who don't have a mortgage payment are not the poorer ones.

But a mortgage payment was an example. What point are you even trying to make? That people who don't own a home have no loan payments whatsoever? The people who don't own a home would seem to be more likely to have a car loan or credit card debt.

Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by eli_gottlieb on Saturday March 19, 2016 @01:25PM (#11319409)
Inflation is a redistribution of wealth from creditors to debtors. Deflation is a distribution from debtors to creditors.

To see which classes it affects, just look at who owes money and who's owed money.

Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by look_lookatme on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:02PM (#11319620)
You are being pithy -- what exactly are you trying to say here?
Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by eli_gottlieb on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:26PM (#11320770)
Not trying to be pithy. I'm saying that in a country where 80% of the population are net-debtors[1], inflation constitutes downward wealth redistribution, whereas it would constitute upward wealth redistribution in a country (conceivable, but seemingly unlikely) in which the wealthy borrow while the poor lend.

[1] -- http://www.cnbc.com/2015/07/29/eight-in-10-americans-are-in-...

Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by chillwaves on Sunday March 20, 2016 @01:16PM (#11323695)
The wealthy certainly leverage debt for their gain as much as the poor, or more so. Your logic seems to have a hole.
Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by nkurz on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:32PM (#11320799)
He's saying that inflation hurts those who are owed money, and helps those who owe money. The people who are owed money are more likely to be rich. The people who owe money tend to be poor. Thus the immediate effect of inflation is to redistribute wealth from the rich to the poor.

The open question is what the longer term effects of inflation will be: who benefits, and who loses, once the system again reaches equilibrium. But based on history, I think we can assume that low inflation works out well for those who already hold lots of capital.

Re:Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:04PM (#11320906)
> But based on history, I think we can assume that low inflation works out well for those who already hold lots of capital.

Based on history, everything works out well for those who already hold lots of capital.

About the only exceptions are widespread economic destruction, violent revolutions, and that thing the transistor did to "those who already hold lots of capital" but invested it in the manufacture of typewriters and carbon paper.

And only the last one really helps the common people.