Whether you do or don't believe it, it's whether they did, and yes they did. Users overwhelmingly chose to not purchase Netscape products which killed their revenue and shut down the company. The competition was free vs paid, and as often happens, paid will fail. If it was free vs free, maybe Netscape would have had a shot.
I could agree that the browsers were at least comparable, until Netscape disappeared and MS had little incentive to improve IE.
Which led to feature stagnation until the Firefox rose from the ashes...
I 100% believe IE 5 was a far superior product than the competing Netscape 4.x. Previous to IE 5, maybe it's debatable.
I worked in a shop in 2000/2001 that was doing early Ajax type stuff (for a dashboard that controlled some embedded hardware.) It wasn't possible to port it to Firefox even at that point, even at that point IE had some leg up.
Later, MS let IE6 bit rot forever. And it was loathsome.
Microsoft tightly integrated IE with Windows, leveraging their OS monopoly in order to beat Netscape. I don't believe MS built a superior product.