Re:Richard P. Feynman - The Relation of Science and Religion
by amichail on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @02:41AM
(#1131105)
First, a number of studies have concluded that by any reasonable measure, atheists tend to be more ethical than religious people as a whole. This shows up in under-representation in criminal activity, lower divorce rates, etc. (There are a number of sociological reasons for this, but those are the statistics.)
What about if you compare atheists and religious people of similar intelligence? I suspect atheists tend to be more ethical simply because they tend to be more intelligent.
Re:Richard P. Feynman - The Relation of Science and Religion
by btilly on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @04:48AM
(#1131229)
The correlation between education and atheism is one of the sociological reasons I was referring to. Unfortunately I do not have access to any research that tries to control for this obviously correlated factor.
First, a number of studies have concluded that by any reasonable measure, atheists tend to be more ethical than religious people as a whole. This shows up in under-representation in criminal activity, lower divorce rates, etc. (There are a number of sociological reasons for this, but those are the statistics.)
Secondly surveys that I saw a long time ago suggest that Feynman was wrong about most scientists in his day. At that time most scientists were religious. (Still at lower rates than the general public.) However most elite scientists were atheists. Which supports the thesis that the more seriously you take science, the harder it is to subscribe to traditional religion.
But this has shifted over time. While looking for that old survey I ran across http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/23/national/23believers.html?... which says that today about 40% of scientists believe in a personal God that they pray to, etc. But if you look at members of the National Academy of Sciences (an elite group of scientists), about 10% believe in God.
So it seems that, in yet another way, Feynman was a man ahead of his time...