News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard P. Feynman - The Relation of Science and Religion by btilly on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @09:00PM (#1130590)
I am a huge advocate and fan of empirical science and all that has brought us, but when people go clobbering religious believers with the science bat as if they're somehow "more certain" about that which they cannot empirically experience, nor empirically reproduce, then that's when I call BS. On existential issues (the only legitimate grounds of disagreement between science and religion), Science and Religion are equal. They are equally uncertain, although many people can't understand that. Both have a mountain of faith-based assumptions about things we cannot EVER determine empirically.

Faith, after all, is being certain of what one cannot see.

By your argument you should personally be equally uncertain about whether gravity works on the surface of Pluto and whether I am a giant octopus. After all you are unable to travel to Pluto, and you are unable to track me down and verify that it was not a giant octopus who wrote these words. In your words, both are claims about things that you "cannot empirically experience nor empirically reproduce."

Yet despite your inability to empirically experience or empirically reproduce either gravity on Pluto or any data pertaining to my octopus-hood, I confidently assert that you do not find your uncertainty on those two issues to be even remotely equivalent.

Why not? Because you have established mental models of how the universe work that make it difficult to believe that gravity doesn't work on Pluto and make it difficult to believe that there are giant octopuses posting on HN. Yet this is exactly the type of certainty that you say you'd call BS on in others. And if you met someone who strongly believed that I am a giant octopus, and expected you to accept it, I'm sure you'd be rather flabbergasted.

Science is nothing less or more than the distillation of the successes of several centuries of work on producing and testing better mental models of how parts of the universe exist. Mental models exactly like the ones you used to tackle the data points I gave you. (In fact every part of the mental model you'd use on the Pluto question, including belief in the existence of Pluto, came out of that scientific process.)

Please think about this example carefully. Then try to apply modern mental models of the universe to questions such as whether people get possessed by demons, water can turn into wine, and people can come back from the dead. You should find that those questions all look far more like the giant octopus claim than gravity on Pluto.

Whether or not this list of dubious factual claims in the Bible changes your belief system any, I think it is sufficient to make concrete why it is not just BS for people with a strong science background to look at a concrete religious tradition (Christianity in this case) and dispute specific claims that religion makes. Even though it involves reasoning about events that you "cannot empirically experience nor empirically reproduce".

And once someone has disputed the basic facts of the central story, what grounds are left to accept the other beliefs of the religion?

Re:Richard P. Feynman - The Relation of Science and Religion by kirse on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @09:13PM (#1130620)
Where did I say that I, personally had to empirically experience something to accept it as fact? I edited my post in case it caused confusion.

All I meant was that I will only accept science that is grounded in empiricism, because that is the only basis for concrete, logical, conclusions from science.

Where science and religion differ (the unempirical), I'm going with my own intuition and convictions, because science is no more correct or certain than religion.

Just in case though, can you get on Skype so I can make sure I'm not arguing with an octopus? =P

Re:Richard P. Feynman - The Relation of Science and Religion by ThomPete on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @02:38AM (#1131098)
Huh?

Science is the only thing that can be correct if we follow your own interpretation.

To be correct about something it requires empirical evidence to measure up against lack of evidence.

By definition religious claims can't be verified so they can never be true.