Re:Open Sourcers Race to Build Better Versions of Slack
by stephenr on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:15AM
(#11302712)
> Well, it failed to be the preferred solution for its problem domain,
Google Talk, Facebook Chat, Origin (EA), Playstation, Cisco WebEx, WhatsApp all use/used XMPP for instant messaging.
That sounds like it's the preferred solution for realtime messaging, with vendor lock-in and NIH syndrome decisions being the major reasons that it isn't used in even more situations.
> and is universally ignored by big players.
As evidenced by the above list of major deployments, it is absolutely not "universally ignored". The problem (as someone else pointed out) is that for many of the "big players" a federated protocol is not what they want, so they don't allow federation, and don't allow/publicise the use of standard XMPP clients.
> Google also killed Talk in favor of Hangouts (and the later doesn't talk to XMPP).
This is a reason to stop using Google services, not a reason to claim XMPP is ill-suited to the task at hand.
Google Talk, Facebook Chat, Origin (EA), Playstation, Cisco WebEx, WhatsApp all use/used XMPP for instant messaging.
That sounds like it's the preferred solution for realtime messaging, with vendor lock-in and NIH syndrome decisions being the major reasons that it isn't used in even more situations.
> and is universally ignored by big players.
As evidenced by the above list of major deployments, it is absolutely not "universally ignored". The problem (as someone else pointed out) is that for many of the "big players" a federated protocol is not what they want, so they don't allow federation, and don't allow/publicise the use of standard XMPP clients.
> Google also killed Talk in favor of Hangouts (and the later doesn't talk to XMPP).
This is a reason to stop using Google services, not a reason to claim XMPP is ill-suited to the task at hand.