News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by nerdponx on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @06:51PM (#11301300)
Yep, I was stuck by how lucid the discussion was. The "remove the computer" idea is powerful.
Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by delinka on Thursday March 17, 2016 @07:40AM (#11303727)
Exactly this makes me feel that turning Obama's "fetishizing our [smart]phones" comment back at his branch of government is plausible. The executive branch has fetishized the smartphone (and started paying it as much attention as a locked safe inside a locked house) - and therefore deserves as much protection as any other part of our private lives.
Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by abraae on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @09:46PM (#11302080)
djb strikes me as the most lucid person on the planet.

His style extends to his software - he offered a bounty for a verifiable security hole in his qmail software in 1997 which still stands today. Nobody has ever found any security holes in qmail. https://cr.yp.to/qmail/guarantee.html

Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by viraptor on Thursday March 17, 2016 @12:42AM (#11302625)
qmail is... specific. It does very little and does it in many different processes. That's kind of like putting a security guarantee on `cat`. In practice qmail on its own is not really usable these days (does it even compile without patches anymore?). The extensions to it are also not even standardised - it mainly happens by patching the source.

I'm not saying that software is bad, but the security guarantee is too restricted to be practical anymore.

Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by quesera on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:25AM (#11302862)
qmail is not a modern MTA, that is true.

But qmail was a revelation in 1996, and a solid choice for at least ten years, despite never reving past 1.03. Those ten years were pretty ugly in the network services security world. djb's bounty was a significant statement in a crazy era.

No one uses qmail any more. But it was used by everyone who ran serious mail servers for a long time. The guarantee was well-tested.

It is not coincidental that Postfix uses a very similar multiprocess model. That is how you encapsulate security domains. djb didn't invent it, but he shined the light for everyone who followed.

Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by viraptor on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:40AM (#11303019)
I agree it was very novel and useful. But in my mind it seats somewhere between a technology preview and a project. Most weird stuff happens to applications that get new features, get redesigned, get new aspects that weren't accounted for before.

You can cut out a lot of security issues by defining ahead of time what you're going to support, writing only that, and never doing anything else. New, small code rarely has terrible design flaws if there was a good plan ahead of time (and djb had an AWESOME plan) and you write it by yourself. Now if you live with a project for a long time, and actually maintain and extend it - that's would be even greater achievement. Postfix went in the similar direction as you mentioned and started around the time qmail got stable, but still lives.

Re:Thomas Jefferson and Apple versus the FBI by quesera on Thursday March 17, 2016 @09:50PM (#11309266)
Those are all great points. I think it's fair to say that djb built the reference model, and Wietse built the consumer product.

Relatedly, djb is an academic who releases code sometimes, and Wietse is a sponsored open source developer. Their methods are very different, but they've both made huge and complementary contributions.