Re:Tumblr Stole My [Subdomain] At The Behest of A Corporation
by ajross on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @04:48PM
(#1130001)
That's overstating the case. The DMCA doesn't require instant take-down, it promises the converse: if you take it down in a timely manner upon receipt of a complaint, you cannot be held liable. The hosting provider is allowed to make its own determination about the validity of the claim, and in fact most do.
This law makes any noncompliant service a "publisher", liable for all content on the site - unless you follow the DMCA. Upon receiving a takedown notice, the service provider must take down content immediately, and issue a notice to the supposed actual content owner. Content owner has a short period in which he can file a counter claim and keep the content up for a little bit while the two sides argue.
Service provider becomes a publisher, liable for your potentially illegal content (trademark/copyright infringement, slander, libel, child pornography, etc) if they do not comply.
Rackspace is not the problem - the 105th Congress was the problem.