Even if we could somehow guarantee absolutely that the backdoor will only be used by the intended users, backdoors are still not acceptable. For much the same reason that it's not acceptable to put a camera in every home or car, even if the footage were "only" accessible by the government with a warrant.
I'm not sure the camera analogy will carry weight. It sounds hyperbolic to most people as it tries to equate actually being recorded in your private affairs to the possibility of materials being accessed when a warrant is issued.
Most people have no problem with law enforcement accessing evidence when a warrant is issued. The only way to win over the general population is to demonstrate encryption is fundamentally different then simple access.