Re:Intel Marrying FPGA, Beefy Broadwell for Open Compute Future
by deadgrey19 on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @03:12PM
(#11292203)
RDMA/kernel bypass NICs work by mapping chunks of RAM and then automatically DMA'ing packets into those chunks. Again, it would be a pretty round about way to give the FPGA access to packets to copy data to RAM, then copy down to the FPGA, then copy back up to RAM. Much simpler/better to let the data stream through the FPGA from/to the wire. In addition, the PHY/MAC layers these days are pretty thin for Ethernet style devices and modern FPGA's are by comparison huge. I'm not saying it can't be done, I'm just saying it seems sub-optimal when FPGA's already have a ton of I/O resources and are already used as NICs. The question as to wether these resources are exposed to the outside world is the salient one.
Plenty of "kernel bypass" and RDMA type functions use shared/user-space memory for "zero-copy" (in reality one copy), operations between NIC and software. If a similar scheme can be used with the FPGA then it would not have too much overhead. I agree, not as direct/efficient as having FPGA serdes I/O go directly to some SPF+/network transceiver, but then you'd also be taking up valuable FPGA gate capacity to run NIC PHY/MAC and standard L2/L3 processing functions that you get from a NIC.