News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama at SXSW: ‘Absolutist view’ on digital privacy canno... by pdonis on Monday March 14, 2016 @12:22PM (#11283716)
> That was your answer to the question I posed.

It most certainly was not. I said you could tell your friend that you're sorry and you hope the people responsible are caught and punished. I said nothing about giving a speech at the wake on the dangers of giving up privacy. You said it wouldn't play well, which is of course true; but that's precisely why you don't want to have that discussion at a wake. You want to have it when there's no immediate issue at hand, so people can be reasonably objective.

> The hard part is what do you say when you have to look someone in the eye and explain yourself.

If your friend comes and asks you point blank why you're against giving up privacy, given what happened to his family, then you have to answer him, yes. But that is worlds different from making a speech, unprompted, at a wake.

If he asks you, your honest answer would have to be that, while you are sorry about his family and hope that the people responsible are caught and punished, you still believe that, in the long run, the dangers of excessive government power are greater than the dangers of terrorism. (That's assuming, of course, that you actually do believe that. But if not, what's the point of the hypothetical?) What else can you say? Your friend probably won't like it, but he's your friend; you've got to be honest with him.

> That's why we have to be willing to discuss it also.

You're missing the point. We can't discuss it because we don't know the facts. And we can't be told the facts because, if there is any benefit to the surveillance, making public how much benefit we get would destroy the benefit. That's why all of these activities are kept secret in the first place.

> Otherwise they have to make the determination and we all get to sit back and throw rocks at them.

We can, but nothing forces us to. Anyone who believes it's worth it for the government to do mass surveillance, and any other covert activities for that matter, has to also be willing to not criticize decisions made based on data that can't be made public. Otherwise they're just a hypocrite who wants the benefits without the costs. I would say that the main source of hypocrisy about that is not individual citizens, but the press.

There are no comments on this comment yet.