Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by hodwik on Monday March 14, 2016 @01:42PM
(#11284205)
> "Expanding the money supply lets people buy more locally produced stuff, but not more imports."
Right, so for most developed nations this would be disastrous.
Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by kaonashi on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:07PM
(#11284391)
The worst you can be imposed on you (outside an embargo situation) is balanced trade, paying for real imports with fx acquired through real exports.
Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by hodwik on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @09:49PM
(#11294429)
Which, for the US, would be a very serious downgrade from our current situation.
Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by kaonashi on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @10:40PM
(#11294606)
Depends on your position in the current situation.
Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by hodwik on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @10:27AM
(#11297545)
Well, then let's clarify:
For almost all Americans -- who produce essentially nothing of value, yet consume a lot of very real, imported goods -- balanced trade would be a complete disaster.
Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by kaonashi on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @02:02PM
(#11299367)
Trade deficits are definitely a net positive, but that lack of demand they cause actively harm a large swath of Americans.
There's a reason NAFTA has been so unpopular.
Re:Ignored for Years, Modern Money Theory Is Gaining Converts
by rogersmith on Monday March 14, 2016 @12:13PM
(#11283663)
" a government has a large amount of power to dictate money flows within the country, but very little power to compel terms of trade overseas."
Isn't the petrodollar system precisely the historical exception that allows the USA to have a lot of power when it comes to "compel terms of trade overseas"?
edit: obviously the other side of that ability to "compel terms of trade overseas" being the US formidable military power that allows them to further twist other countries arms when they refuse to play by the petrodollar system rules (see Libya, Iraq, etc)
MMT absolutely does take account of forex by recognising that a government has a large amount of power to dictate money flows within the country, but very little power to compel terms of trade overseas. And most countries need to continuously import certain things which cannot be substituted locally, especially fuel.
Expanding the money supply lets people buy more locally produced stuff, but not more imports. This even scales down to local token currencies ("Bristol pound") or Krugman's "babysitting tokens" thought example.