News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by tptacek on Monday February 15, 2010 @09:17PM (#1128119)
Your point about DHH having no experience with VC is somewhat valid (they don't think Bezos counts), but your point about "small business" versus "startup" is completely devoid of meaning. You don't need to take VC to be a startup, and you don't need to exit inside of 5 years to be a startup either.

An uncharitable summary of your argument: 37signals has been too successful to know what they're talking about.

Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by statictype on Monday February 15, 2010 @10:53PM (#1128257)
>An uncharitable summary of your argument: 37signals has been too successful to know what they're talking about.

That's not a completely unreasonable argument to make. The fact that they were able to achieve success without having to take in investor money, in some ways disqualifies them from giving advice on when its ok to take investments.

Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by fnid2 on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @01:35AM (#1128473)
Were they successful without taking investors money? I mean, they took investors money, so how do we know? We don't know how much Bezos gave them, it could have been millions. I don't know. Maybe someone knows, but to say they were able to achieve success without having to take investor money isn't entirely accurate, because they did.
Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by tptacek on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @10:36AM (#1129003)
DHH explicitly said they didn't receive operational cash from Bezos in his interview with Steve Blank's class. They took the money to get tight with Bezos and to trade some equity for risk mitigation.
Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by fnid2 on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @11:45AM (#1129153)
I don't find this argument compelling. It doesn't matter why you take the money. It matters that you took the money and keep saying it doesn't matter. If it doesn't matter, why did they take it? For the benefits and they did benefit from it, so they can't keep saying they haven't taken investors money and be credible.
Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by tptacek on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @04:52PM (#1130019)
I disagree. Manager-types call the years where you spend more money than you should "investment years", as in, you're investing in the business. If they took the money and are sitting on it, they clearly are't running the standard VC company playbook.
Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by fnid2 on Wednesday February 17, 2010 @01:28AM (#1131008)
You're making too many assumptions. Who says they are sitting on the money? Who says they didn't spend it on rent and salaries when they didn't have any other money coming in? Maybe they spent it on publishing their book or adwords or off shoring. Who knows?
Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by sabat on Monday February 15, 2010 @11:41PM (#1128335)
your point about "small business" versus "startup" is completely devoid of meaning

Small businesses usually aim to stay small businesses; 37signals is not going to grow to 500 employees and become like Salesforce. Startups, whether or not they take funding, aim for larger success and an exit, either a buyout or an IPO (whether it's within 5 years is beside the point). Those differences account for a big difference in management strategy.

An uncharitable summary of your argument: 37signals has been too successful to know what they're talking about.

You've misunderstood me. Since I think that there's a big difference in running a startup vs. running a small business, I don't think it makes sense for DHH to presume to give business advice to startups. Jeff Bezos? Sure, he could give advice; he's had a startup.

Re:All the wrong reasons for Stack Overflow's VC chase by _delirium on Tuesday February 16, 2010 @06:01AM (#1128680)
Until recently, I hadn't actually heard that definition of startup, at least outside of VCs talking to each other (because obviously VCs only care about the subset of startups that involve VCs and, ideally, large-multiplier exits). But in general I've thought of a "startup" as simply a new business based on technology. Some subset of startups were funded by venture capitalists, and a subset were aiming to grow huge and have quick exits. But others aimed at medium-sized businesses, or even smallish businesses. A large proportion of the people I know who've founded startups actively don't want an "exit", because they built it, and they aren't going to give it up anytime soon.

I'm not even really sure how it became that people assumed that startups ought to aim for large funding and under-5-year exits. Is that just a legacy of the fact that anyone with eyeballs could (and therefore, often did) get funding in the first bubble, so it just became assumed that it was the norm?