Re:The Next Front in the New Crypto Wars: WhatsApp
by hifier on Sunday March 13, 2016 @09:53PM
(#11280556)
Not until they change the 5th amendment.
Re:The Next Front in the New Crypto Wars: WhatsApp
by 0xcde4c3db on Monday March 14, 2016 @12:33AM
(#11281089)
I don't know what the accepted jurisprudence is on this, but there are interpretations of the 5th amendment saying that the protection only extends to the authorities being unable to legally compel you to reveal that you can decrypt the data (and, by extension, that you have some level of knowledge of or responsibility for it). That is, if they can somehow prove that the data is yours, a court can order you to decrypt it.
In the US, you will be held in contempt for failing to decrypt data when ordered if they can show that you "probably" have access to it and it's relevant to the charges against you. This also means prison for many years for failure to decrypt, even if you can't.