Whereas, good human players learned as they went with far fewer matches, trial and error, planning, and learning from pto games sometimes. We can even go from Age of Empires to Starcraft with little prrparation and still do OK.
That worked with backgammon without any problems. (http://www.bkgm.com/articles/tesauro/tdl.html)
In Go, a naive approach would probably also work, but would take ages. There's probably a slightly smarter approach possible.
When the AI is cognizant of the fact that Go is a game, and knows what a game is, and perceives that the game is taking place in a larger reality, where there are other things happening while the game is going on....then I'll be impressed.
Or maybe not. The history of AI is one of humans always moving the goalposts when AI advances.
Chess? just a computationally simple game. Driving? Well it's just physics. Go? now that requires intelligence oh wait, just some deep neural savant thing, not real AI
You can make some analogies between sparse matrix data representations and what happens in the mammalian neocortex. It is of course not self conscious, but it effectively deals with semantic information and relationships among it.
The sheer amount of computing power that AlphaGo needs will be a problem for games as complicated as Go for people who aren't Google. There will probably be more activity in simpler games with interesting properties.
Non-game applications will require a fully formalized set of rules. The fact that formalizing what you want is hard is the reason we need programmers in the first place, so nothing fundamentally different there.
I did some work for a Forex trader. He had devised an algorithm for trading and used it daily for modest gains. He engaged me to automate it for him via the vWorker freelance website [1]. I got the engine going getting the realtime price data etc. But when it came to his system it didn't work. In practice he didn't always act upon the signals he thought he did. We ended up in payment dispute because he insisted that if I had done the work right then the bot would be making money. By this time, I had learned the error of his thinking. We arbitrated on 50% payment - I wasn't too pleased with that but I had learned about trading.
I do feel that given all the hype and speculation about strong AI researchers in Deep Learning should really come forward to contextualize the real impact of this - which I think is not all that great.
You can expect a lot of advancement in actual games very soon, including ones with randomness, and after a few years probably hidden information games too. Being able to specify real-world problems as formally as a board game is now a more effective skill than it was before (it was good already).
It is also good enough to put it in a combat drone that visually recognizes objectives and people. This can be all commanded by a small group of people, anonymously, and detached from accountability and without casualties.
To say nothing of the casualties that'll be inflected on the AI warriors...
Did any credible skeptics actually claim this would never happen? If so, I'd love to hear their reasoning.
Autonomous vehicles are similar. IMO, it would be a fool's bet to bet against them ever happening. But it's reasonable to debate whether they'll be mainstream Level 4 consumer devices in 10 years, 25 years, or 50 years.
Now, being more specific about Go:
- Lee Sedol himself was confident he would win.
- Ke Jie said he would win against AlphaGo. I think he would lose too.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_...
That's already happening, at least somewhat, right?
[Link](https://medium.com/@peterbsmith/computer-beats-human-at-hard...)
My grandfather was very racist and never changed as long as he lived. I'm glad most people aren't immortal. There's no guarantee a full AI wouldn't be tempted by evil and just become republican (or worse, a VC).
It can also recursively improve itself.
So can people (the more you know, the more you can learn), but most don't. It's important to remember "intelligence" isn't an abstract concept—intelligence is also embodied in personality—and personalities have wishes and goals and desires and loves and hates and that one song they can't get out of their head. A true "strong AI" will be fully conscious, not just algorithmic function bating.
Good luck telling a mildly strong godform to stop tripping on youtube videos and instead solve the global economic stability equation over lunch.
This advantage will lower the bar for strong AI even more.
That's kinda foofy conjecture. Being good at rectangular grid outcomes isn't necessarily a step in any direction towards a hands-off tax evaluating robot.
It feels really really good to talk about how AI will be a hundred billion trillion times smarter than the combined brainpower of all humans that have ever lived, but it feels good in the same way thinking dead people live again after they die feels good—it triggers that warm wishful thinking parietal lobe that removes a bit of reason for the sake of an overarching calmness.
Enthusiasm is great, but tempering with real expectations and less technopriesthood is better.
Now, while many people die and their ideas die with them, there are built in aspects of our brain that are hardwired. People eat animals because they are tasty, people follow the life of Kim Kardashian and waste money buying a rolex and wear fur just because the stupid way our social functions are hardwired in our brain.
Fresh minds don't have the burden of outdated ideas... quoting Max Planck: "a new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
We are primitive forms of life after all and are at the point where we should be able to say, with certainty, that machine intelligence will be objectively superior and something that we should feel OBLIGATED to give rise to, regardless of consequences.
There is no prescribed script about what our evolutionary value should be. We will be whatever we ourselves make of us. Unless something unexpected happens -more advanced aliens intervening with our specie for example- Our human instinct is to grow, explore, discover, compete, share as much as we can. AI should be seen as a tool to our goals. Not as an end by itself. There is of course the possibility that we may loose control to the AI. That is not our desired goal, but it could happen. In that case our future will not be our decision. We will be at the mercy of whatever the AI choose for us. That will depend on what kind of AI we built, and how the rampant AI chooses to modify itself. But we will strive to reach our human goals. Because that is the human nature.
"We will be whatever we ourselves make of us" sounds meaningless to me. The universe obeys certain physical laws, evolution is directed and follows a specific pattern. We have up to this point been bound by both. Occam's razor says this will continue to be the case.
I think we are already at the crossroads where we can more than speculate about the function of machine intelligence in evolutionary terms, but hopefully sooner rather than later we will have actual _evidence_ that we can look at and use to refine our assumptions.
It took Lee Sedol many decades of his life to train to achieve this level. And his ability to pass on his skills is limited. Now that a computer has achieved this level, the state of the neural network behind it can be serialized and ran into an unlimited number of computers and have millions of systems that are more proficient at Go than the best player in the world.
People have said that achieving the cognitive level of the human brain requires to match its computational power. But if you take out all the parasympathetic and motor boilerplate, what is actually left for mental tasks is much less from that, most of that power is not even recruited for higher level mental tasks. That lowers the bar for strong AI.
Then, strong AI can be immortal, and never physically deteriorate from aging. Strong AI can multiply infinitely and communicate at a rate that would be equivalent to writing millions of books in a second. It could transfer all its knowledge in seconds. It can also recursively improve itself. This advantage will lower the bar for strong AI even more.